- 2026-04-22 6mo Seton Hall Pirates 5 at Monmouth Hawks 6 Nick Lovarco MON 2/4 2hr 2rbi
- 2025-04-23 1y Monmouth Hawks 3 at Seton Hall Pirates 8
- 2024-03-19 2y Monmouth Hawks 5 at Seton Hall Pirates 6
- 2023-03-15 3y Monmouth Hawks 2 at Seton Hall Pirates 1 Mason Miller MON 2.2ip 0h 0er 1k
- 2022-04-12 4y Seton Hall Pirates 6 at Monmouth Hawks 7 Casey Caufield MON 1/3
- 2022-03-29 4y Monmouth Hawks 3 at Seton Hall Pirates 4 Devin Hack SETON 0/4
- 2019-04-16 7y Seton Hall Pirates 6 at Monmouth Hawks 3 Nick Payero SETON 3.0ip 0h 0er 4k
- 2019-03-24 7y Seton Hall Pirates 12 at Monmouth Hawks 2 Tyler Shedler-McAvoy SETON 2/5 1hr 3rbi
- 2018-04-18 8y Monmouth Hawks 10 at Seton Hall Pirates 3 James Kelly MON 4.0ip 1h 1er 2k
- 2017-05-16 9y Monmouth Hawks 7 at Seton Hall Pirates 2 Brian Reiss MON 6.2ip 2h 1er 3k
- 2016-04-19 10y Monmouth Hawks 3 at Seton Hall Pirates 13 Joe Poduslenko SETON 1/4 1hr 5rbi
- 2015-04-21 11y Seton Hall Pirates 2 at Monmouth Hawks 0 Anthony Pacillo SETON 9.0ip 0h 0er 7k
- 2015-04-14 11y Monmouth Hawks 3 at Seton Hall Pirates 1 Jeff Paglione MON 3.0ip 0h 0er 3k
- 2014-04-22 12y Monmouth Hawks 3 at Seton Hall Pirates 4 Anthony Pacillo SETON 7.1ip 1h 1er 5k
- 2013-04-23 13y Seton Hall Pirates 10 at Monmouth Hawks 1 Giuseppe Papaccio SETON 2/5 1hr 3rbi
- 2012-04-24 14y Seton Hall Pirates 15 at Monmouth Hawks 3 Scott Kalamar SETON 4/6 1hr 6rbi