- 2027-01-05 in 2mo Aston Villa at Everton
- 2026-12-01 in 1mo Everton at Aston Villa
- 2026-01-18 9mo Everton 1 at Aston Villa 0 James Garner ENG-EVER 90min yc
- 2025-09-13 1y Aston Villa 0 at Everton 0
- 2025-01-15 1y Aston Villa 1 at Everton 0 Ollie Watkins ENG-ASTO 90min
- 2024-09-14 2y Everton 2 at Aston Villa 3 Ollie Watkins ENG-ASTO 84min 2g
- 2024-01-14 2y Aston Villa 0 at Everton 0
- 2023-09-27 3y Everton 2 at Aston Villa 1 James Garner ENG-EVER 90min 1g
- 2023-02-25 3y Aston Villa 2 at Everton 0 John McGinn ENG-ASTO 90min 1a
- 2022-08-13 4y Everton 1 at Aston Villa 2 Ollie Watkins ENG-ASTO 90min 2a
- 2022-01-22 4y Aston Villa 1 at Everton 0 Damián Emiliano Martínez ENG-ASPV 90min yc
- 2021-09-18 5y Everton 0 at Aston Villa 3 Matty Cash ENG-ASPV 86min 1g
- 2021-05-13 5y Everton 0 at Aston Villa 0
- 2021-05-01 5y Aston Villa 2 at Everton 1 Ollie Watkins ENG-ASPV 90min 1g
- 2020-07-16 6y Aston Villa 1 at Everton 1
- 2016-03-01 10y Everton 3 at Aston Villa 1 José Ramiro Funes Mori ENG-EVFJ 90min 1g
- 2015-11-21 10y Aston Villa 0 at Everton 4 Ross Barkley ENG-EVFJ 74min 2g
- 2015-05-02 11y Everton 2 at Aston Villa 3 Christian Benteke Liolo ENG-ASPV 90min 2g
- 2014-10-18 12y Aston Villa 0 at Everton 3 Phil Jagielka ENG-EVFJ 90min 1g
- 2014-02-01 12y Aston Villa 1 at Everton 2 Kevin Mirallas ENG-EVFJ 90min 1g
- 2013-10-26 13y Everton 2 at Aston Villa 0 Romelu Lukaku Menama ENG-EVFJ 90min 1g
- 2013-02-02 13y Aston Villa 3 at Everton 3
- 2012-08-25 14y Everton 3 at Aston Villa 1 Steven Pienaar ENG-EVER 90min 1g
- 2012-01-14 14y Everton 1 at Aston Villa 1
- 2011-09-10 15y Aston Villa 2 at Everton 2
- 2011-04-02 15y Aston Villa 2 at Everton 2
- 2010-08-29 16y Everton 0 at Aston Villa 1 Luke Young ENG-ASPV 90min 1g
- 2010-04-14 16y Everton 2 at Aston Villa 2
- 2009-10-31 17y Aston Villa 1 at Everton 1
- 2009-04-12 17y Everton 3 at Aston Villa 3
- 2009-02-15 17y Aston Villa 1 at Everton 3 Mikel Arteta Amatriain ENG-EVFJ 90min 1g
- 2008-12-07 17y Aston Villa 3 at Everton 2 Ashley Young ENG-ASPV 90min 2g
- 2008-04-27 18y Aston Villa 2 at Everton 2
- 2007-09-23 19y Everton 0 at Aston Villa 2 John Alieu Carew ENG-ASPV 53min 1g
- 2007-04-02 19y Everton 1 at Aston Villa 1
- 2006-11-11 19y Aston Villa 1 at Everton 0 Chris Sutton ENG-ASPV 90min 1g
- 2006-03-18 20y Aston Villa 1 at Everton 4 Leon Osman ENG-EVFJ 90min 1g
- 2005-12-26 20y Everton 0 at Aston Villa 4 Milan Baroš ENG-ASPV 90min 2g
- 2005-02-26 21y Everton 3 at Aston Villa 1 Leon Osman ENG-EVER 90min 2g
- 2004-10-30 22y Aston Villa 1 at Everton 1
- 2004-02-28 22y Aston Villa 0 at Everton 2 Thomas Gravesen ENG-EVFJ 90min 1g yc
- 2003-10-25 23y Everton 0 at Aston Villa 0
- 2003-04-25 23y Aston Villa 1 at Everton 2
- 2002-09-21 24y Everton 2 at Aston Villa 3
- 2002-01-29 24y Everton 0 at Aston Villa 0
- 2001-10-19 25y Aston Villa 2 at Everton 3
- 2001-04-13 25y Everton 1 at Aston Villa 2
- 2000-11-04 25y Aston Villa 1 at Everton 0
- 1999-11-26 26y Aston Villa 0 at Everton 0
- 1999-08-10 27y Everton 0 at Aston Villa 3