- 2026-02-14 8mo Newcastle United FC 3 at Aston Villa 1 Malick Thiaw ENG-NEWC 90min yc
- 2026-01-25 9mo Aston Villa 2 at Newcastle United FC 0 Emiliano Martínez ENG-ASTO 90min
- 2025-08-16 1y Newcastle United FC 0 at Aston Villa 0
- 2025-08-16 1y Aston Villa 0 at Newcastle United FC 0
- 2025-04-19 1y Newcastle United FC 1 at Aston Villa 4 Ollie Watkins ENG-ASTO 83min 1g 1a
- 2024-01-30 2y Newcastle United FC 3 at Aston Villa 1 Fabian Lukas Schär ENG-NEWC 90min
- 2023-04-15 3y Newcastle United FC 0 at Aston Villa 3 Ollie Watkins ENG-ASTO 90min
- 2022-10-29 4y Aston Villa 0 at Newcastle United FC 4 Callum Wilson ENG-NEJP 86min 2g 1a
- 2022-02-13 4y Aston Villa 0 at Newcastle United FC 1 Kieran Trippier ENG-NEJP 48min 1g
- 2021-08-21 5y Newcastle United FC 0 at Aston Villa 2 Anwar El Ghazi ENG-ASPV 90min 1g
- 2021-03-12 5y Aston Villa 1 at Newcastle United FC 1
- 2021-01-23 5y Newcastle United FC 0 at Aston Villa 2 Ollie Watkins ENG-ASPV 90min 1g
- 2020-06-24 6y Aston Villa 1 at Newcastle United FC 1
- 2019-11-25 6y Newcastle United FC 0 at Aston Villa 2 Conor Hourihane ENG-ASPV 90min 1g
- 2017-02-21 9y Aston Villa 0 at Newcastle United FC 2 Yoan Gouffran ENG-NEJP 89min 1g
- 2016-09-24 10y Newcastle United FC 1 at Aston Villa 1
- 2016-05-07 10y Newcastle United FC 0 at Aston Villa 0
- 2015-12-19 10y Aston Villa 1 at Newcastle United FC 1
- 2015-02-28 11y Aston Villa 0 at Newcastle United FC 1 Papiss Demba Cissé ENG-NEJP 90min 1g
- 2014-02-23 12y Aston Villa 0 at Newcastle United FC 1 Loïc Alex Teliére Hubert Rémy ENG-NEJP 90min 1g yc
- 2013-09-14 13y Newcastle United FC 2 at Aston Villa 1 Hatem Ben Arfa ENG-NEJP 90min 1g
- 2013-01-29 13y Newcastle United FC 2 at Aston Villa 1 Yohan Cabaye ENG-NEWC 90min 1g
- 2012-09-02 14y Aston Villa 1 at Newcastle United FC 1
- 2012-02-05 14y Aston Villa 1 at Newcastle United FC 2 Demba Ba ENG-NEJP 90min 1g
- 2011-09-17 15y Newcastle United FC 1 at Aston Villa 1
- 2011-04-10 15y Newcastle United FC 0 at Aston Villa 1 James Collins ENG-ASPV 90min 1g
- 2010-08-22 16y Aston Villa 0 at Newcastle United FC 6 Andy Carroll ENG-NEJP 90min 3g
- 2009-05-24 17y Newcastle United FC 0 at Aston Villa 1 Brad Friedel ENG-ASPV 90min
- 2008-11-03 17y Aston Villa 0 at Newcastle United FC 2 Obafemi Akinwunmi Martins ENG-NEJP 88min 2g yc
- 2008-02-09 18y Newcastle United FC 1 at Aston Villa 4 John Alieu Carew ENG-ASPV 90min 3g yc
- 2007-08-18 19y Aston Villa 0 at Newcastle United FC 0
- 2007-01-31 19y Aston Villa 1 at Newcastle United FC 3 Kieron Dyer ENG-NEJP 90min 1g
- 2006-08-27 20y Newcastle United FC 0 at Aston Villa 2 Juan Pablo Ángel Arango ENG-ASPV 90min 1g
- 2006-02-11 20y Newcastle United FC 2 at Aston Villa 1 ENG-NEJP 85min (sub in 5) 1g
- 2005-12-03 20y Aston Villa 1 at Newcastle United FC 1
- 2005-04-02 21y Aston Villa 3 at Newcastle United FC 0 Gareth Barry ENG-ASPV 90min 2g
- 2004-08-28 22y Newcastle United FC 2 at Aston Villa 4 Olof Mellberg ENG-ASPV 90min 1g
- 2004-04-18 22y Newcastle United FC 0 at Aston Villa 0
- 2003-11-01 22y Aston Villa 1 at Newcastle United FC 1
- 2003-04-20 23y Aston Villa 1 at Newcastle United FC 1
- 2002-12-06 23y Newcastle United FC 1 at Aston Villa 0
- 2002-04-01 24y Newcastle United FC 1 at Aston Villa 1
- 2001-11-02 24y Aston Villa 0 at Newcastle United FC 3
- 2001-05-18 25y Aston Villa 0 at Newcastle United FC 3
- 2000-12-01 25y Newcastle United FC 1 at Aston Villa 1
- 1999-12-03 26y Newcastle United FC 1 at Aston Villa 0
- 1999-01-29 27y Aston Villa 1 at Newcastle United FC 2
- 1998-09-08 28y Newcastle United FC 0 at Aston Villa 1
- 1998-01-31 28y Newcastle United FC 1 at Aston Villa 0
- 1997-08-22 29y Aston Villa 0 at Newcastle United FC 1