- 2026-08-28 1mo William & Mary Tribe 35 at Villanova Wildcats 32 Winston Watkins CWM 19/33-254yd 21run-72yd 2td 1td
- 2025-09-27 1y William & Mary Tribe 24 at Villanova Wildcats 31 Pat McQuaide NOVA 15/28-194yd
- 2022-11-12 3y Villanova Wildcats 12 at William & Mary Tribe 45 Darius Wilson CWM 15/12-211yd 8run-95yd 3td 1td
- 2021-10-30 4y William & Mary Tribe 31 at Villanova Wildcats 18 Darius Wilson CWM 10/18-109yd 11run-yd 1td
- 2019-10-05 7y Villanova Wildcats 35 at William & Mary Tribe 28 Daniel Smith NOVA 21/34-250yd 6run-24yd 3td
- 2015-10-10 11y William & Mary Tribe 38 at Villanova Wildcats 16 Steve Cluley CWM 16/28-267yd 6run-3yd 1td
- 2014-10-18 11y Villanova Wildcats 35 at William & Mary Tribe 31 John Robertson NOVA 20/32-267yd 18run-63yd 2td 2td
- 2013-10-05 13y William & Mary Tribe 16 at Villanova Wildcats 20 John Robertson NOVA 21/28-154yd 18run-70yd 1td
- 2011-10-01 15y William & Mary Tribe 20 at Villanova Wildcats 16 Michael Graham CWM 13/24-171yd 6run-8yd
- 1978-09-23 48y William & Mary Tribe 21 at Villanova Wildcats 17
- 1977-10-01 49y Villanova Wildcats 8 at William & Mary Tribe 28
- 1973-10-06 53y Villanova Wildcats 21 at William & Mary Tribe 33
- 1972-09-23 54y William & Mary Tribe 17 at Villanova Wildcats 20
- 1969-11-15 56y William & Mary Tribe 21 at Villanova Wildcats 35
- 1968-11-02 57y Villanova Wildcats 12 at William & Mary Tribe 33
- 1966-10-08 60y Villanova Wildcats 14 at William & Mary Tribe 34