- 2010-11-20 15y New Mexico Lobos 7 at BYU Cougars 40
- 2009-11-14 16y BYU Cougars 24 at New Mexico Lobos 19
- 2008-10-11 18y New Mexico Lobos 3 at BYU Cougars 21
- 2007-09-29 19y BYU Cougars 31 at New Mexico Lobos 24
- 2006-11-18 19y New Mexico Lobos 17 at BYU Cougars 42
- 2005-10-08 21y BYU Cougars 27 at New Mexico Lobos 24
- 2004-11-13 21y New Mexico Lobos 21 at BYU Cougars 14
- 2003-09-13 23y BYU Cougars 10 at New Mexico Lobos 7
- 2002-11-16 23y New Mexico Lobos 20 at BYU Cougars 16
- 2001-10-13 25y BYU Cougars 24 at New Mexico Lobos 20
- 2000-11-18 25y New Mexico Lobos 13 at BYU Cougars 37
- 1999-10-16 27y BYU Cougars 31 at New Mexico Lobos 7
- 1998-11-07 27y New Mexico Lobos 21 at BYU Cougars 46
- 1997-11-15 28y BYU Cougars 28 at New Mexico Lobos 38
- 1996-09-21 30y New Mexico Lobos 14 at BYU Cougars 17
- 1995-11-11 30y BYU Cougars 31 at New Mexico Lobos 14
- 1994-09-24 32y New Mexico Lobos 47 at BYU Cougars 49
- 1993-09-04 33y BYU Cougars 34 at New Mexico Lobos 31
- 1992-11-07 33y New Mexico Lobos 0 at BYU Cougars 35
- 1991-10-26 34y BYU Cougars 41 at New Mexico Lobos 23
- 1990-10-29 35y New Mexico Lobos 31 at BYU Cougars 55
- 1989-09-02 37y BYU Cougars 24 at New Mexico Lobos 3
- 1988-10-29 37y New Mexico Lobos 0 at BYU Cougars 65
- 1987-09-26 39y BYU Cougars 45 at New Mexico Lobos 25
- 1986-09-13 40y New Mexico Lobos 30 at BYU Cougars 31
- 1985-10-19 40y BYU Cougars 45 at New Mexico Lobos 23
- 1984-10-25 41y BYU Cougars 48 at New Mexico Lobos 0
- 1983-10-15 43y New Mexico Lobos 21 at BYU Cougars 66
- 1982-10-09 44y BYU Cougars 40 at New Mexico Lobos 12
- 1981-10-31 44y New Mexico Lobos 7 at BYU Cougars 31
- 1980-09-06 46y BYU Cougars 21 at New Mexico Lobos 25
- 1979-10-27 46y New Mexico Lobos 7 at BYU Cougars 59
- 1978-09-30 48y BYU Cougars 27 at New Mexico Lobos 23
- 1977-09-30 49y New Mexico Lobos 19 at BYU Cougars 54
- 1976-11-13 49y BYU Cougars 21 at New Mexico Lobos 8
- 1975-10-03 51y New Mexico Lobos 15 at BYU Cougars 16
- 1974-11-16 51y BYU Cougars 36 at New Mexico Lobos 3
- 1973-11-03 52y New Mexico Lobos 21 at BYU Cougars 56
- 1972-11-25 53y BYU Cougars 21 at New Mexico Lobos 7
- 1971-10-01 55y New Mexico Lobos 14 at BYU Cougars 0
- 1970-11-14 55y BYU Cougars 8 at New Mexico Lobos 51
- 1969-10-11 57y New Mexico Lobos 15 at BYU Cougars 41
- 1968-11-23 57y BYU Cougars 35 at New Mexico Lobos 6
- 1967-09-23 59y New Mexico Lobos 14 at BYU Cougars 44
- 1966-10-22 59y BYU Cougars 33 at New Mexico Lobos 6
- 1965-11-27 60y BYU Cougars 42 at New Mexico Lobos 8
- 1964-10-02 62y New Mexico Lobos 26 at BYU Cougars 14
- 1963-11-30 62y BYU Cougars 0 at New Mexico Lobos 26
- 1962-11-03 63y New Mexico Lobos 0 at BYU Cougars 27
- 1961-11-25 64y BYU Cougars 6 at New Mexico Lobos 34