- 2027-02-20 in 3mo Chatham Cougars at Bethany (W.V.) Bison
- 2027-01-20 in 2mo Bethany (W.V.) Bison at Chatham Cougars
- 2026-02-04 9mo Bethany (W.V.) Bison 74 at Chatham Cougars 67 Kaedlee Potter BTHWV 33m 12p 14r 4a 3b
- 2025-12-10 10mo Chatham Cougars 43 at Bethany (W.V.) Bison 58 Ella Simpson BTHWV 32m 16p 4r 3a
- 2025-02-25 1y Bethany (W.V.) Bison 59 at Chatham Cougars 61 Alyssa Laukus CHTHM 31m 16p 7r 1a 2b
- 2025-02-12 1y Chatham Cougars 84 at Bethany (W.V.) Bison 51 Charjae Brock CHTHM 30m 17p 5r 2a
- 2025-01-04 1y Bethany (W.V.) Bison 50 at Chatham Cougars 75 Charjae Brock CHTHM 36m 14p 7r 4a 1b
- 2024-02-22 2y Bethany (W.V.) Bison 56 at Chatham Cougars 66 Ashlie Louden CHTHM 32m 17p 7r 2a
- 2024-01-24 2y Bethany (W.V.) Bison 56 at Chatham Cougars 77 Ashlie Louden CHTHM 24m 23p 2r 4a
- 2023-11-29 2y Chatham Cougars 88 at Bethany (W.V.) Bison 59 Aurielle Brunner CHTHM 33m 18p 1r 3a
- 2023-01-28 3y Chatham Cougars 63 at Bethany (W.V.) Bison 57 Zelimar Rodriguez CHTHM 28m 8p 8r 2a
- 2022-12-03 3y Bethany (W.V.) Bison 48 at Chatham Cougars 92 Ashlie Louden CHTHM 20m 15p 9r 4a
- 2022-02-22 4y Bethany (W.V.) Bison 64 at Chatham Cougars 44 Lindsey Garrison BTHWV 39m 10p 3r
- 2022-02-12 4y Bethany (W.V.) Bison 38 at Chatham Cougars 67 Julianna Skowron CHTHM 30m 12p 8r 3b
- 2022-01-31 4y Chatham Cougars 55 at Bethany (W.V.) Bison 46 Sierra McClain CHTHM 31m 10p 3r 2a
- 2021-02-16 5y Chatham Cougars 56 at Bethany (W.V.) Bison 61 Bella Skobel BTHWV 35m 13p 3r 3a 1b
- 2020-02-08 6y Chatham Cougars 55 at Bethany (W.V.) Bison 62 Kelsie Meintel BTHWV 35m 16p 16r 3a
- 2020-01-08 6y Bethany (W.V.) Bison 60 at Chatham Cougars 74 Kaitlyn Fertig CHTHM 38m 29p 4r 3a
- 2019-02-02 7y Bethany (W.V.) Bison 50 at Chatham Cougars 60 Katie Sieg CHTHM 40m 22p 8r 3a
- 2019-01-03 7y Chatham Cougars 55 at Bethany (W.V.) Bison 67 Ashley Duthie BTHWV 37m 16p 8r 3a 2b
- 2018-02-14 8y Chatham Cougars 44 at Bethany (W.V.) Bison 58 Kelsea Daugherty BTHWV 40m 24p 13r 2a 2b
- 2018-01-17 8y Bethany (W.V.) Bison 77 at Chatham Cougars 40 Makayla Reynolds BTHWV 24m 22p 7r 1a
- 2017-02-20 9y Chatham Cougars 74 at Bethany (W.V.) Bison 61 Jesse Hinkle CHTHM 27m 22p 10r 2a 3b
- 2017-02-15 9y Bethany (W.V.) Bison 83 at Chatham Cougars 48 Kelsea Daugherty BTHWV 36m 31p 16r 3a
- 2017-01-18 9y Chatham Cougars 78 at Bethany (W.V.) Bison 83 Kelsea Daugherty BTHWV 33m 26p 12r
- 2016-02-06 10y Chatham Cougars 64 at Bethany (W.V.) Bison 55 Megan Sieg CHTHM 36m 19p 4r 4a
- 2016-01-02 10y Bethany (W.V.) Bison 88 at Chatham Cougars 80 Hayley Holenka BTHWV 28m 21p 10r 3a
- 2015-02-07 11y Bethany (W.V.) Bison 83 at Chatham Cougars 65 Kelsea Daugherty BTHWV 29m 28p 9r 2a
- 2015-01-03 11y Chatham Cougars 45 at Bethany (W.V.) Bison 85 Kelsea Daugherty BTHWV 19m 18p 9r 1a
- 2014-02-12 12y Bethany (W.V.) Bison 87 at Chatham Cougars 78 Taylor Verrico BTHWV 31m 21p 11r 1a
- 2014-01-15 12y Chatham Cougars 56 at Bethany (W.V.) Bison 70 Taylor Verrico BTHWV 34m 14p 9r 2a
- 2013-02-06 13y Chatham Cougars 58 at Bethany (W.V.) Bison 68 Taylor Verrico BTHWV 28m 21p 9r 2a 1b
- 2013-01-09 13y Bethany (W.V.) Bison 77 at Chatham Cougars 58 Mikyla Tipton BTHWV 28m 13p 7r 3a 1b
- 2012-01-28 14y Chatham Cougars 67 at Bethany (W.V.) Bison 77 Kayla Taormina BTHWV 35m 24p 7r 6a
- 2011-12-07 14y Bethany (W.V.) Bison 72 at Chatham Cougars 48 Kayla Taormina BTHWV 31m 12p 11r 1a