- 2026-11-15 in 4w Miami Dolphins at Indianapolis Colts
- 2025-09-07 1y Miami Dolphins 8 at Indianapolis Colts 33 Daniel Jones IND 22/29-272yd 7run-26yd 1td 2td
- 2024-10-20 1y Miami Dolphins 10 at Indianapolis Colts 16 Anthony Richardson IND 10/24-129yd 14run-56yd
- 2021-10-03 5y Indianapolis Colts 27 at Miami Dolphins 17 Carson Wentz IND 24/32-228yd 5run-8yd 2td
- 2019-11-10 6y Miami Dolphins 16 at Indianapolis Colts 12 Ryan Fitzpatrick MIA 21/33-169yd 4run-23yd 1td
- 2018-11-25 7y Miami Dolphins 24 at Indianapolis Colts 27 Andrew Luck IND 30/37-343yd 2run-5yd 1rec-4yd 3td
- 2015-12-27 10y Indianapolis Colts 18 at Miami Dolphins 12 Matt Hasselbeck IND 8/15-99yd
- 2013-09-15 13y Miami Dolphins 24 at Indianapolis Colts 20 Ryan Tannehill MIA 23/34-319yd 4run-1yd 1td
- 2012-11-04 13y Miami Dolphins 20 at Indianapolis Colts 23 Andrew Luck IND 30/48-433yd 1run-5yd 2td
- 2009-09-21 17y Indianapolis Colts 27 at Miami Dolphins 23 Peyton Manning IND 14/23-303yd 1run-3yd 2td
- 2006-12-31 19y Miami Dolphins 22 at Indianapolis Colts 27 Peyton Manning IND 22/37-282yd 1run-11yd 2td 1td
- 2003-11-02 22y Indianapolis Colts 23 at Miami Dolphins 17 Peyton Manning IND 23/37-266yd 1td
- 2002-09-15 24y Miami Dolphins 21 at Indianapolis Colts 13 Jay Fiedler MIA 13/18-187yd 7run-30yd 2td 1td
- 2001-12-10 24y Indianapolis Colts 6 at Miami Dolphins 41 Jay Fiedler MIA 18/26-191yd 1run-9yd 3td 1td
- 2001-11-11 24y Miami Dolphins 27 at Indianapolis Colts 24 Jay Fiedler MIA 17/29-259yd 2run-8yd 2td
- 2000-12-30 25y Indianapolis Colts 17 at Miami Dolphins 23 Jay Fiedler MIA 19/34-185yd 7run-43yd 1td
- 2000-12-17 25y Indianapolis Colts 20 at Miami Dolphins 13
- 2000-11-26 25y Miami Dolphins 17 at Indianapolis Colts 14 Damon Huard MIA 22/33-183yd 1td
- 1999-12-05 26y Indianapolis Colts 37 at Miami Dolphins 34
- 1999-10-10 27y Miami Dolphins 34 at Indianapolis Colts 31
- 1998-11-08 27y Indianapolis Colts 14 at Miami Dolphins 27
- 1998-09-06 28y Miami Dolphins 24 at Indianapolis Colts 15
- 1997-12-14 28y Miami Dolphins 0 at Indianapolis Colts 41
- 1997-08-31 29y Indianapolis Colts 10 at Miami Dolphins 16
- 1996-11-10 29y Indianapolis Colts 13 at Miami Dolphins 37
- 1996-09-23 30y Miami Dolphins 6 at Indianapolis Colts 10
- 1995-11-26 30y Miami Dolphins 28 at Indianapolis Colts 36
- 1995-10-08 31y Indianapolis Colts 27 at Miami Dolphins 24
- 1994-12-18 31y Miami Dolphins 6 at Indianapolis Colts 10
- 1994-11-06 31y Indianapolis Colts 21 at Miami Dolphins 22
- 1993-10-24 32y Indianapolis Colts 27 at Miami Dolphins 41
- 1993-09-05 33y Miami Dolphins 24 at Indianapolis Colts 20
- 1992-11-08 33y Miami Dolphins 28 at Indianapolis Colts 0
- 1992-10-25 33y Indianapolis Colts 31 at Miami Dolphins 20
- 1991-11-03 34y Miami Dolphins 10 at Indianapolis Colts 6
- 1991-09-08 35y Indianapolis Colts 6 at Miami Dolphins 17
- 1990-12-30 35y Indianapolis Colts 17 at Miami Dolphins 23
- 1990-10-28 35y Miami Dolphins 27 at Indianapolis Colts 7
- 1989-12-17 36y Miami Dolphins 13 at Indianapolis Colts 42
- 1989-11-05 36y Indianapolis Colts 13 at Miami Dolphins 19
- 1988-12-04 37y Indianapolis Colts 31 at Miami Dolphins 28
- 1988-09-25 38y Miami Dolphins 13 at Indianapolis Colts 15
- 1987-11-15 38y Indianapolis Colts 40 at Miami Dolphins 21
- 1987-09-20 39y Miami Dolphins 23 at Indianapolis Colts 10
- 1986-10-26 39y Miami Dolphins 17 at Indianapolis Colts 13
- 1986-09-14 40y Indianapolis Colts 10 at Miami Dolphins 30
- 1985-11-17 40y Miami Dolphins 34 at Indianapolis Colts 20
- 1985-09-15 41y Indianapolis Colts 13 at Miami Dolphins 30
- 1984-12-09 41y Miami Dolphins 35 at Indianapolis Colts 17
- 1984-09-23 42y Indianapolis Colts 7 at Miami Dolphins 44