MIN
BUF
1
2
3
4
- 1 1 15:00 CHI Bills won the coin toss. Bills to receive the opening kickoff. 0-0
- 2 1 15:00 MIN Mitch Berger kicks off 71 yards. Returned by Chris Watson for 21 yards. Tackle by Jim Nelson. 0-0
- 3 1 14:51 BUF Sammy Morris up the middle run. 6 yard gain. Tackle by Ed McDaniel. 0-0
- 4 1 14:18 BUF Sammy Morris left run. 3 yard gain. Tackle by Robert Griffith. 0-0
- 5 1 13:46 BUF Sammy Morris left run. 5 yard gain. Tackle by Robert Griffith. 0-0
- 6 1 13:10 BUF Doug Flutie pass incomplete. Intended for Shawn Bryson. Defended by Talance Sawyer. 0-0
- 7 1 13:06 BUF Shawn Bryson up the middle run. 2 yard gain. Tackle by Tony Williams and Kailee Wong. 0-0
- 8 1 12:29 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Jeremy McDaniel. 9 yard gain. Tackle by Kenny Wright. Penalty on Marcus Spriggs: Offensive Holding, 10 yards. No play. 0-0
- 9 1 12:04 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Shawn Bryson for no gain. 0-0
- 10 1 11:27 BUF Chris Mohr punts 39 yards. Fair catch by Troy Walters. 0-0
- 11 1 11:19 BUF Robert Smith right run. 5 yard gain. Tackle by Ted Washington. 0-0
- 12 1 10:45 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass incomplete. Intended for Johnny McWilliams. 0-0
- 13 1 10:38 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass incomplete. Intended for Matthew Hatchette. 0-0
- 14 1 10:34 MIN Mitch Berger punts 43 yards. Returned by Chris Watson for 3 yards. Tackle by Moe Williams. 0-0
- 15 1 10:22 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Eric Moulds. 10 yard gain. Tackle by Orlando Thomas. 0-0
- 16 1 9:47 BUF Sammy Morris up the middle run. 2 yard gain. Tackle by Chris Hovan. 0-0
- 17 1 9:09 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Jeremy McDaniel. 7 yard gain. Tackle by Ed McDaniel. 0-0
- 18 1 8:26 BUF Sammy Morris left run for no gain. Tackle by Dwayne Rudd. 0-0
- 19 1 7:49 BUF Chris Mohr punts 45 yards. Returned by Troy Walters for 13 yards. Tackle by Ethan Albright. 0-0
- 20 1 7:37 BUF Robert Smith left run. 5 yard gain. Tackle by Keith Newman and John Holecek. 0-0
- 21 1 7:02 BUF Robert Smith right run. 5 yard gain. Tackle by Sam Rogers. Penalty on Marcellus Wiley: Defensive Offside, 5 yards. No play. 0-0
- 22 1 6:31 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass complete to Randy Moss. 28 yard gain. Tackle by Keion Carpenter. 0-0
- 23 1 5:59 BUF Robert Smith left run. 5 yard gain. Tackle by Henry Jones. 0-0
- 24 1 5:21 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass complete to Johnny McWilliams for no gain. 0-0
- 25 1 4:32 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass incomplete. Intended for Cris Carter. Penalty on Erik Flowers: Defensive Offside, 5 yards. No play. 0-0
- 26 1 4:26 BUF Robert Smith up the middle run. 5 yard gain. Tackle by Ted Washington. 0-0
- 27 1 3:44 BUF Robert Smith right run. 3 yard gain. Tackle by Phil Hansen and Sam Cowart. 0-0
- 28 1 3:44 MIN Penalty on Daunte Culpepper: Delay of Game, 5 yards. No play. 0-0
- 29 1 2:38 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass incomplete. Intended for Randy Moss. 0-0
- 30 1 2:38 MIN Gary Anderson 38 yard field goal. Good. MIN 0-3
- 31 1 2:38 MIN Mitch Berger kicks off 71 yards. Returned by Chris Watson for 19 yards. Tackle by Antonio Banks. MIN 0-3
- 32 1 2:17 BUF Doug Flutie pass incomplete. Intended for Eric Moulds. MIN 0-3
- 33 1 2:13 BUF Shawn Bryson right end run. 7 yard gain. Tackle by Robert Griffith. MIN 0-3
- 34 1 1:29 BUF Doug Flutie pass incomplete. Intended for Jeremy McDaniel. MIN 0-3
- 35 1 1:26 BUF Chris Mohr punts 41 yards. Fair catch by Troy Walters. MIN 0-3
- 36 1 1:18 BUF Robert Smith right run. 4 yard gain. Tackle by Sam Cowart and Ted Washington. MIN 0-3
- 37 1 0:39 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass incomplete. Intended for Cris Carter. MIN 0-3
- 38 1 0:34 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass incomplete. Intended for Cris Carter. Defended by Ken Irvin. MIN 0-3
- 39 1 0:30 MIN Penalty on MIN: False Start, 5 yards. No play. MIN 0-3
- 40 1 0:30 MIN Mitch Berger punts 40 yards. Returned by Chris Watson for 20 yards. Tackle by Mitch Berger. MIN 0-3
- 41 1 0:19 BUF Doug Flutie pass incomplete. Intended for Peerless Price. MIN 0-3
- 42 1 0:16 BUF Shawn Bryson left run. 24 yard gain. Tackle by Cris Dishman. MIN 0-3
- 43 2 15:00 BUF Sammy Morris left run. 2 yard gain. Tackle by Ed McDaniel. MIN 0-3
- 44 2 14:25 BUF Sammy Morris up the middle run. 2 yard gain. Tackle by Dwayne Rudd. MIN 0-3
- 45 2 13:44 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Eric Moulds. 25 yard gain. Touchdown. BUF 6-3
- 46 2 13:44 BUF Steve Christie kicks extra point. Good. BUF 7-3
- 47 2 13:44 BUF Steve Christie kicks off 53 yards. Returned by Troy Walters for 12 yards. Tackle by Antoine Winfield. BUF 7-3
- 48 2 13:29 MIN Daunte Culpepper up the middle run. 2 yard gain. Tackle by Pat Williams. BUF 7-3
- 49 2 12:46 BUF Robert Smith left run. 3 yard gain. Tackle by Ted Washington and Pat Williams. BUF 7-3
- 50 2 12:03 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass incomplete. Intended for Randy Moss. Defended by Sam Cowart. BUF 7-3
- 51 2 12:03 MIN Mitch Berger punts 53 yards. Fair catch by Chris Watson. BUF 7-3
- 52 2 11:49 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Jeremy McDaniel. 2 yard gain. Tackle by Cris Dishman. BUF 7-3
- 53 2 11:49 BUF Penalty on BUF: Illegal Substitution, 5 yards. No play. BUF 7-3
- 54 2 10:52 BUF Doug Flutie left run. 8 yard gain. Tackle by Dwayne Rudd. BUF 7-3
- 55 2 10:12 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Jeremy McDaniel. 9 yard gain. Tackle by Kailee Wong. BUF 7-3
- 56 2 9:33 MIN Jonathan Linton up the middle run. 9 yard gain. Tackle by Dwayne Rudd. BUF 7-3
- 57 2 8:54 MIN Jonathan Linton up the middle run for no gain. Tackle by Chris Hovan and Robert Griffith. BUF 7-3
- 58 2 8:11 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Eric Moulds. 6 yard gain. Tackle by Robert Tate. BUF 7-3
- 59 2 7:33 BUF Doug Flutie sacked by Kailee Wong. 8 yard loss. BUF 7-3
- 60 2 7:00 BUF Shawn Bryson up the middle run. 4 yard gain. Tackle by Ed McDaniel. BUF 7-3
- 61 2 6:19 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Peerless Price. 18 yard gain. Tackle by Robert Griffith. BUF 7-3
- 62 2 5:38 BUF Doug Flutie pass incomplete. Intended for Eric Moulds. BUF 7-3
- 63 2 5:33 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Eric Moulds. 13 yard gain. Tackle by Robert Tate. BUF 7-3
- 64 2 4:54 BUF Doug Flutie pass incomplete. Intended for Peerless Price. BUF 7-3
- 65 2 4:49 BUF Sammy Morris up the middle run. 5 yard gain. Tackle by Orlando Thomas and Kailee Wong. BUF 7-3
- 66 2 4:04 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Eric Moulds. 5 yard gain. Tackle by Kenny Wright. BUF 7-3
- 67 2 3:35 BUF Sammy Morris up the middle run for no gain. Tackle by Robert Griffith. BUF 7-3
- 68 2 2:54 BUF Shawn Bryson up the middle run. 8 yard gain. Tackle by Robert Griffith and John Burrough. BUF 7-3
- 69 2 2:14 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Eric Moulds. 5 yard gain. Tackle by Cris Dishman. BUF 7-3
- 70 2 2:00 BUF Sammy Morris up the middle run. 1 yard loss. Tackle by Ed McDaniel. BUF 7-3
- 71 2 1:18 BUF Sammy Morris left end run for no gain. Tackle by Robert Tate. Penalty on Peerless Price: Illegal Crackback, 15 yards. No play. BUF 7-3
- 72 2 1:11 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Sammy Morris. 8 yard gain. Tackle by Ed McDaniel. BUF 7-3
- 73 2 1:05 BUF Timeout by Minnesota Vikings. BUF 7-3
- 74 2 1:05 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Eric Moulds. 9 yard gain. Tackle by Robert Griffith and John Burrough. BUF 7-3
- 75 2 0:58 BUF Timeout by Minnesota Vikings. BUF 7-3
- 76 2 0:58 BUF Steve Christie 25 yard field goal. Good. BUF 10-3
- 77 2 0:58 BUF Steve Christie kicks off 49 yards. Returned by Troy Walters for 14 yards. Tackle by Antoine Winfield. BUF 10-3
- 78 2 0:50 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass incomplete. Intended for Cris Carter. BUF 10-3
- 79 2 0:50 MIN Replay Assistant challenged the ruling. And the original play was overturned. 0-0
- 80 2 0:37 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass complete to Randy Moss. 28 yard gain. Tackle by Antoine Winfield and Daryl Porter. BUF 10-3
- 81 2 0:29 MIN Timeout by Minnesota Vikings. BUF 10-3
- 82 2 0:29 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass complete to Cris Carter. 28 yard gain. Cris Carter fumbles. Recovered by Cris Carter at BUF-9. BUF 10-3
- 83 2 0:17 MIN Daunte Culpepper up the middle run. 6 yard gain. Tackle by Keion Carpenter. Penalty on Daryl Porter: Delay of Game, 2 yards. BUF 10-3
- 84 2 0:09 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass incomplete. Intended for Cris Carter. BUF 10-3
- 85 2 0:03 MIN Gary Anderson 20 yard field goal. Good. BUF 10-6
- 86 3 15:00 BUF Steve Christie kicks off 55 yards. Returned by Moe Williams for 16 yards. Tackle by Kenyatta Wright. BUF 10-6
- 87 3 14:51 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass complete to Matthew Hatchette. 13 yard gain. Tackle by Ken Irvin. BUF 10-6
- 88 3 14:17 BUF Robert Smith left run. 5 yard gain. Tackle by Sam Rogers and John Holecek. BUF 10-6
- 89 3 13:43 BUF Robert Smith right run. 4 yard gain. Tackle by Henry Jones and Sam Cowart. BUF 10-6
- 90 3 12:59 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass complete to Randy Moss. 4 yard gain. Tackle by Ken Irvin. BUF 10-6
- 91 3 12:23 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass complete to Cris Carter. 16 yard gain. Tackle by Antoine Winfield. BUF 10-6
- 92 3 11:49 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass complete to Johnny McWilliams. 10 yard gain. Tackle by Henry Jones. BUF 10-6
- 93 3 11:22 BUF Robert Smith up the middle run. 7 yard gain. Tackle by John Holecek and Sam Cowart. BUF 10-6
- 94 3 10:37 BUF Robert Smith right run. 2 yard gain. Tackle by John Holecek. BUF 10-6
- 95 3 9:52 MIN Daunte Culpepper left end run. 2 yard gain. Tackle by John Holecek. BUF 10-6
- 96 3 9:21 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass complete to Cris Carter. 6 yard gain. Touchdown. MIN 10-12
- 97 3 9:21 MIN Gary Anderson kicks extra point. Good. MIN 10-13
- 98 3 9:21 MIN Mitch Berger kicks off 75 yards. Touchback. MIN 10-13
- 99 3 9:10 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Eric Moulds. 5 yard gain. Tackle by Kailee Wong. MIN 10-13
- 100 3 8:35 BUF Sammy Morris left end run. 2 yard gain. Tackle by Kailee Wong. MIN 10-13
- 101 3 7:55 BUF Doug Flutie pass incomplete. Intended for Peerless Price. Penalty on Kenny Wright: Defensive Pass Interference, 5 yards. No play. MIN 10-13
- 102 3 7:55 BUF Penalty on John Fina: False Start, 5 yards. No play. MIN 10-13
- 103 3 7:45 BUF Shawn Bryson right end run. 3 yard gain. Tackle by Ed McDaniel and Dwayne Rudd. MIN 10-13
- 104 3 7:05 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Shawn Bryson. 17 yard gain. Tackle by Ed McDaniel. MIN 10-13
- 105 3 6:19 BUF Shawn Bryson up the middle run. 2 yard gain. Tackle by Tony Williams. MIN 10-13
- 106 3 5:39 BUF Doug Flutie pass incomplete. Intended for Eric Moulds. Defended by Orlando Thomas. MIN 10-13
- 107 3 5:31 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Eric Moulds. 20 yard gain. Eric Moulds fumbles. Recovered by Eric Moulds at MIN-31. MIN 10-13
- 108 3 5:00 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Peerless Price. 9 yard gain. Tackle by Cris Dishman. MIN 10-13
- 109 3 5:00 Penalty on Marcus Spriggs: False Start, 5 yards. No play. MIN 10-13
- 110 3 4:00 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Jeremy McDaniel. 13 yard gain. Tackle by Ed McDaniel. MIN 10-13
- 111 3 3:26 BUF Sammy Morris up the middle run. 3 yard gain. Tackle by Talance Sawyer. MIN 10-13
- 112 3 2:43 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Kwame Cavil. 9 yard gain. Tackle by Orlando Thomas. MIN 10-13
- 113 3 1:58 BUF Sammy Morris up the middle run. 1 yard gain. Tackle by Chris Hovan. MIN 10-13
- 114 3 1:16 BUF Sammy Morris up the middle run. 1 yard gain. Touchdown. BUF 16-13
- 115 3 1:16 BUF Steve Christie kicks extra point. Good. BUF 17-13
- 116 3 1:16 BUF Steve Christie kicks off 44 yards. Returned by Troy Walters for 13 yards. Tackle by Travares Tillman. BUF 17-13
- 117 3 1:04 BUF Robert Smith right end run. 2 yard gain. Tackle by John Holecek. BUF 17-13
- 118 3 0:19 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass incomplete. Intended for Matthew Hatchette. Intercepted by Sam Rogers at MIN-44 and returned. 10 yard gain. Tackle by Matthew Hatchette. BUF 17-13
- 119 3 0:13 BUF Shawn Bryson left end run. 19 yard gain. Tackle by Orlando Thomas. BUF 17-13
- 120 4 15:00 BUF Shawn Bryson left run. 3 yard loss. Tackle by Chris Hovan. BUF 17-13
- 121 4 14:28 BUF Timeout by Minnesota Vikings. BUF 17-13
- 122 4 14:28 BUF Doug Flutie pass incomplete. Intended for Jeremy McDaniel. BUF 17-13
- 123 4 14:25 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Sammy Morris. 18 yard gain. Touchdown. BUF 23-13
- 124 4 14:25 BUF Steve Christie kicks extra point. Good. BUF 24-13
- 125 4 14:25 BUF Steve Christie kicks off 56 yards. Returned by Harold Morrow for 17 yards. BUF 24-13
- 126 4 14:10 MIN Daunte Culpepper up the middle run. 3 yard gain. Tackle by Marcellus Wiley. BUF 24-13
- 127 4 13:31 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass complete to Cris Carter. 17 yard gain. Tackle by Keion Carpenter and Donovan Greer. BUF 24-13
- 128 4 12:50 BUF Robert Smith up the middle run. 3 yard gain. Tackle by Leif Larsen and Phil Hansen. BUF 24-13
- 129 4 12:14 Penalty on Todd Steussie: False Start, 5 yards. No play. BUF 24-13
- 130 4 11:59 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass complete to Randy Moss. 11 yard gain. Tackle by Daryl Porter. BUF 24-13
- 131 4 11:15 MIN Timeout by Minnesota Vikings. BUF 24-13
- 132 4 11:15 BUF Penalty on Korey Stringer: False Start, 5 yards. No play. BUF 24-13
- 133 4 11:15 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass incomplete. Intended for Randy Moss. Penalty on Ken Irvin: Defensive Holding, 5 yards. No play. BUF 24-13
- 134 4 11:10 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass complete to Robert Smith. 9 yard gain. Tackle by Sam Cowart and Donovan Greer. BUF 24-13
- 135 4 10:29 BUF Robert Smith right run. 20 yard gain. Tackle by Keion Carpenter and Henry Jones. BUF 24-13
- 136 4 9:38 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass complete to Cris Carter. 11 yard gain. Touchdown. BUF 24-19
- 137 4 9:38 MIN Two Point Attempt: Daunte Culpepper pass complete to Moe Williams. Conversion succeeds. Penalty on Andrew Jordan: Unsportsmanlike Conduct, 15 yards. BUF 24-21
- 138 4 9:38 MIN Mitch Berger kicks off 64 yards. Returned by Chris Watson for 15 yards. Tackle by Chris Walsh. Penalty on Kenny Wright: Offensive Offside, 5 yards. No play. BUF 24-21
- 139 4 9:38 MIN Mitch Berger kicks off 72 yards. Returned by Chris Watson for 33 yards. Tackle by Mitch Berger. BUF 24-21
- 140 4 9:11 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Jeremy McDaniel. 8 yard gain. Tackle by Cris Dishman. BUF 24-21
- 141 4 8:35 BUF Shawn Bryson left end run. 8 yard gain. Tackle by Kailee Wong and Orlando Thomas. BUF 24-21
- 142 4 8:01 Penalty on Ruben Brown: False Start, 5 yards. No play. BUF 24-21
- 143 4 7:36 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Eric Moulds. 7 yard gain. Tackle by Robert Tate. BUF 24-21
- 144 4 6:52 BUF Doug Flutie pass incomplete. Intended for Eric Moulds. Defended by Robert Tate. BUF 24-21
- 145 4 6:48 BUF Doug Flutie pass incomplete. Intended for Eric Moulds. BUF 24-21
- 146 4 6:48 BUF Steve Christie 48 yard field goal. Good. BUF 27-21
- 147 4 6:48 BUF Steve Christie kicks off 62 yards. Returned by Moe Williams for 34 yards. Tackle by Kwame Cavil. BUF 27-21
- 148 4 6:27 MIN Daunte Culpepper left end run. 6 yard gain. Tackle by Sam Rogers. BUF 27-21
- 149 4 5:45 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass incomplete. Intended for Cris Carter. BUF 27-21
- 150 4 5:40 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass incomplete. Intended for Randy Moss. BUF 27-21
- 151 4 5:40 MIN Mitch Berger punts 33 yards. Fair catch by Chris Watson. BUF 27-21
- 152 4 5:28 BUF Shawn Bryson left run. 2 yard loss. Tackle by Robert Griffith. BUF 27-21
- 153 4 4:52 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Eric Moulds. 9 yard gain. Tackle by Robert Griffith and Robert Tate. BUF 27-21
- 154 4 4:10 BUF Doug Flutie pass incomplete. Intended for Eric Moulds. BUF 27-21
- 155 4 4:10 BUF Chris Mohr punts 36 yards. Returned by Troy Walters for 28 yards. Tackle by Keith Newman. BUF 27-21
- 156 4 3:54 MIN Penalty on Randy Moss: False Start, 5 yards. No play. BUF 27-21
- 157 4 3:54 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass incomplete. Intended for Matthew Hatchette. BUF 27-21
- 158 4 3:50 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass complete to Randy Moss. 39 yard gain. Touchdown. 27-27
- 159 4 3:50 MIN Gary Anderson kicks extra point. Good. MIN 27-28
- 160 4 3:50 MIN Mitch Berger kicks off 72 yards. Touchback. MIN 27-28
- 161 4 3:36 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Sammy Morris. 9 yard gain. Tackle by Ed McDaniel. MIN 27-28
- 162 4 3:07 BUF Doug Flutie pass incomplete. Intended for Sammy Morris. MIN 27-28
- 163 4 3:02 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Shawn Bryson. 18 yard gain. Tackle by Keith Thibodeaux. Penalty on Marcus Spriggs: Tripping, 10 yards. No play. MIN 27-28
- 164 4 2:54 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Peerless Price. 15 yard gain. Tackle by Robert Tate. Peerless Price fumbles. Forced by Robert Tate. Recovered by Orlando Thomas at BUF-34. Tackle by Sammy Morris. MIN 27-28
- 165 4 2:46 BUF Robert Smith right end run. 1 yard loss. MIN 27-28
- 166 4 2:41 BUF Timeout by Buffalo Bills. MIN 27-28
- 167 4 2:41 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass complete to Cris Carter. 5 yard gain. Tackle by Antoine Winfield. MIN 27-28
- 168 4 2:34 MIN Timeout by Buffalo Bills. MIN 27-28
- 169 4 2:34 Penalty on David Dixon: False Start, 5 yards. No play. MIN 27-28
- 170 4 2:30 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass complete to Cris Carter. 24 yard gain. Tackle by Keion Carpenter. MIN 27-28
- 171 4 2:06 MIN Timeout by Buffalo Bills. MIN 27-28
- 172 4 2:10 BUF Robert Smith left run. 4 yard loss. Tackle by Pat Williams. MIN 27-28
- 173 4 2:00 MIN Daunte Culpepper right end run. 10 yard gain. Tackle by Sam Cowart. MIN 27-28
- 174 4 1:13 MIN Daunte Culpepper pass complete to Johnny McWilliams. 2 yard gain. Tackle by Keion Carpenter. MIN 27-28
- 175 4 1:07 MIN Gary Anderson 21 yard field goal. Good. MIN 27-31
- 176 4 1:07 MIN Mitch Berger kicks off 73 yards. Touchback. MIN 27-31
- 177 4 1:04 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Sammy Morris. 4 yard gain. Tackle by Cris Dishman. MIN 27-31
- 178 4 0:39 BUF Doug Flutie pass incomplete. Intended for Peerless Price. Defended by Kenny Wright. MIN 27-31
- 179 4 0:33 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Eric Moulds. 21 yard gain. Tackle by Cris Dishman. MIN 27-31
- 180 4 0:14 BUF Doug Flutie pass incomplete. Intended for Eric Moulds. MIN 27-31
- 181 4 0:10 BUF Doug Flutie pass complete to Kwame Cavil. 13 yard gain. MIN 27-31
- 182 4 0:05 BUF Doug Flutie pass incomplete. Intended for Eric Moulds. Defended by Robert Griffith. MIN 27-31