- 2026-12-26 in 2mo Cincinnati Bengals at Indianapolis Colts
- 2023-12-10 2y Indianapolis Colts 14 at Cincinnati Bengals 34 Jake Browning CIN 18/24-275yd 3run-7yd 2td 1td
- 2020-10-18 5y Cincinnati Bengals 27 at Indianapolis Colts 31 Philip Rivers IND 29/44-371yd 3td
- 2018-09-09 8y Cincinnati Bengals 34 at Indianapolis Colts 23 Andy Dalton CIN 21/28-243yd 2run-8yd 1tck 2td
- 2017-10-29 8y Indianapolis Colts 23 at Cincinnati Bengals 24 Andy Dalton CIN 17/29-243yd 3run-10yd 2td
- 2015-01-04 11y Cincinnati Bengals 10 at Indianapolis Colts 26 Andrew Luck IND 31/44-376yd 2run-18yd 1td
- 2014-10-19 11y Cincinnati Bengals 0 at Indianapolis Colts 27 Andrew Luck IND 27/42-344yd 4run-5yd 2td
- 2013-12-08 12y Indianapolis Colts 28 at Cincinnati Bengals 42 Andy Dalton CIN 24/35-275yd 5run-11yd 3td 1td
- 2011-10-16 15y Indianapolis Colts 17 at Cincinnati Bengals 27 Andy Dalton CIN 25/32-264yd 1td
- 2010-11-14 15y Cincinnati Bengals 17 at Indianapolis Colts 23 Peyton Manning IND 20/36-185yd
- 2008-12-07 17y Cincinnati Bengals 3 at Indianapolis Colts 35 Peyton Manning IND 26/32-277yd 3td
- 2006-12-18 19y Cincinnati Bengals 16 at Indianapolis Colts 34 Peyton Manning IND 29/36-282yd 2run-10yd 4td
- 2005-11-20 20y Indianapolis Colts 45 at Cincinnati Bengals 37 Peyton Manning IND 24/40-365yd 1tck 3td
- 2002-10-06 24y Cincinnati Bengals 21 at Indianapolis Colts 28 Peyton Manning IND 21/34-224yd 2run-10yd 2td 1td
- 1999-10-24 26y Cincinnati Bengals 10 at Indianapolis Colts 31
- 1998-12-13 27y Cincinnati Bengals 26 at Indianapolis Colts 39
- 1997-11-09 28y Cincinnati Bengals 28 at Indianapolis Colts 13
- 1996-12-22 29y Indianapolis Colts 24 at Cincinnati Bengals 31
- 1995-09-03 31y Cincinnati Bengals 24 at Indianapolis Colts 21
- 1994-11-20 31y Indianapolis Colts 17 at Cincinnati Bengals 13
- 1993-09-12 33y Indianapolis Colts 9 at Cincinnati Bengals 6
- 1992-12-27 33y Indianapolis Colts 21 at Cincinnati Bengals 17
- 1990-11-25 35y Indianapolis Colts 34 at Cincinnati Bengals 20
- 1989-10-22 36y Indianapolis Colts 23 at Cincinnati Bengals 12
- 1987-09-13 39y Cincinnati Bengals 23 at Indianapolis Colts 21
- 1983-10-02 43y Indianapolis Colts 34 at Cincinnati Bengals 31
- 1982-12-05 43y Cincinnati Bengals 20 at Indianapolis Colts 17
- 1981-10-11 45y Cincinnati Bengals 41 at Indianapolis Colts 19
- 1980-12-07 45y Indianapolis Colts 33 at Cincinnati Bengals 34
- 1979-11-04 46y Cincinnati Bengals 28 at Indianapolis Colts 38
- 1976-09-19 50y Cincinnati Bengals 27 at Indianapolis Colts 28
- 1974-11-03 51y Cincinnati Bengals 24 at Indianapolis Colts 14
- 1972-11-19 53y Indianapolis Colts 20 at Cincinnati Bengals 19
- 1970-12-26 55y Cincinnati Bengals 0 at Indianapolis Colts 17