- 2024-12-01 1y Indianapolis Colts 25 at New England Patriots 24 Anthony Richardson IND 12/24-109yd 9run-48yd 2td 1td
- 2023-11-12 2y Indianapolis Colts 10 at New England Patriots 6 Gardner Minshew IND 18/28-194yd
- 2022-11-06 3y Indianapolis Colts 3 at New England Patriots 26 Mac Jones NEP 20/30-147yd 1td
- 2021-12-18 4y New England Patriots 17 at Indianapolis Colts 27 Carson Wentz IND 5/12-57yd 8run-17yd 1td
- 2018-10-04 8y Indianapolis Colts 24 at New England Patriots 38 Tom Brady NEP 34/44-341yd 3td 1td
- 2015-10-18 10y New England Patriots 34 at Indianapolis Colts 27 Tom Brady NEP 23/37-312yd 3td
- 2015-01-18 11y Indianapolis Colts 7 at New England Patriots 45 Tom Brady NEP 23/35-226yd 3run-13yd 3td
- 2014-11-16 11y New England Patriots 42 at Indianapolis Colts 20 Tom Brady NEP 19/30-257yd 2td
- 2014-01-11 12y Indianapolis Colts 22 at New England Patriots 43 Tom Brady NEP 13/25-198yd
- 2012-11-18 13y Indianapolis Colts 24 at New England Patriots 59 Tom Brady NEP 24/35-331yd 3td
- 2011-12-04 14y Indianapolis Colts 24 at New England Patriots 31 Tom Brady NEP 29/38-289yd 3run-7yd 2td
- 2010-11-21 15y Indianapolis Colts 28 at New England Patriots 31 Tom Brady NEP 19/25-186yd 2td
- 2009-11-15 16y New England Patriots 34 at Indianapolis Colts 35 Peyton Manning IND 28/44-327yd 4td
- 2008-11-02 17y New England Patriots 15 at Indianapolis Colts 18 Peyton Manning IND 21/29-254yd 2td
- 2007-11-04 18y New England Patriots 24 at Indianapolis Colts 20 Tom Brady NEP 21/32-255yd 5run-14yd 3td
- 2007-01-21 19y New England Patriots 34 at Indianapolis Colts 38 Peyton Manning IND 27/47-349yd 1td 1td
- 2006-11-05 19y Indianapolis Colts 27 at New England Patriots 20 Peyton Manning IND 20/36-326yd 2td
- 2005-11-07 20y Indianapolis Colts 40 at New England Patriots 21 Peyton Manning IND 28/37-321yd 3run-24yd 3td
- 2005-01-16 21y Indianapolis Colts 3 at New England Patriots 20 Tom Brady NEP 18/27-144yd 4run-6yd 1td 1td
- 2004-09-09 22y Indianapolis Colts 24 at New England Patriots 27 Tom Brady NEP 26/38-335yd 3td
- 2004-01-18 22y Indianapolis Colts 14 at New England Patriots 24 Tom Brady NEP 22/37-237yd 5run-1yd 1td
- 2003-11-30 22y New England Patriots 38 at Indianapolis Colts 34 Tom Brady NEP 26/35-236yd 2td
- 2001-10-21 24y New England Patriots 38 at Indianapolis Colts 17 Tom Brady NEP 16/20-202yd 3td
- 2001-09-30 25y Indianapolis Colts 13 at New England Patriots 44 Tom Brady NEP 13/23-168yd 1run-2yd
- 2000-10-22 25y New England Patriots 23 at Indianapolis Colts 30 Peyton Manning IND 16/20-268yd 3td
- 2000-10-08 26y Indianapolis Colts 16 at New England Patriots 24 Drew Bledsoe NEP 15/23-142yd 2run-15yd 2td
- 1999-12-12 26y New England Patriots 15 at Indianapolis Colts 20
- 1999-09-19 27y Indianapolis Colts 28 at New England Patriots 31
- 1998-11-01 27y New England Patriots 21 at Indianapolis Colts 16
- 1998-09-13 28y Indianapolis Colts 6 at New England Patriots 29
- 1997-11-30 28y Indianapolis Colts 17 at New England Patriots 20
- 1997-09-07 29y New England Patriots 31 at Indianapolis Colts 6
- 1996-11-24 29y Indianapolis Colts 13 at New England Patriots 27
- 1996-10-20 29y New England Patriots 27 at Indianapolis Colts 9
- 1995-12-23 30y New England Patriots 7 at Indianapolis Colts 10
- 1995-11-19 30y Indianapolis Colts 24 at New England Patriots 10
- 1994-12-11 31y Indianapolis Colts 13 at New England Patriots 28
- 1994-11-27 31y New England Patriots 12 at Indianapolis Colts 10
- 1993-12-26 32y Indianapolis Colts 0 at New England Patriots 38
- 1993-10-31 32y New England Patriots 6 at Indianapolis Colts 9
- 1992-12-06 33y Indianapolis Colts 6 at New England Patriots 0
- 1992-11-15 33y New England Patriots 37 at Indianapolis Colts 34
- 1991-12-08 34y Indianapolis Colts 17 at New England Patriots 23
- 1991-09-01 35y New England Patriots 16 at Indianapolis Colts 7
- 1990-11-11 35y Indianapolis Colts 13 at New England Patriots 10
- 1990-09-16 36y New England Patriots 16 at Indianapolis Colts 14
- 1989-12-03 36y Indianapolis Colts 16 at New England Patriots 22
- 1989-10-29 36y New England Patriots 23 at Indianapolis Colts 20
- 1988-11-27 37y New England Patriots 21 at Indianapolis Colts 24
- 1988-10-02 38y Indianapolis Colts 17 at New England Patriots 21