- 2026-10-11 4d Indianapolis Colts 22 at Pittsburgh Steelers 34 Aaron Rodgers PIT 31/22-235yd 1run-6yd 3td
- 2025-11-02 11mo Indianapolis Colts 20 at Pittsburgh Steelers 27 Aaron Rodgers PIT 25/35-203yd 1td
- 2024-09-29 2y Pittsburgh Steelers 24 at Indianapolis Colts 27 Joe Flacco IND 16/26-168yd 2run-3yd 2td
- 2023-12-16 2y Pittsburgh Steelers 13 at Indianapolis Colts 30 Gardner Minshew IND 18/28-215yd 3td
- 2022-11-28 3y Pittsburgh Steelers 24 at Indianapolis Colts 17 Kenny Pickett PIT 20/28-174yd 6run-32yd
- 2020-12-27 5y Indianapolis Colts 24 at Pittsburgh Steelers 28 Ben Roethlisberger PIT 34/49-341yd 3td
- 2019-11-03 6y Indianapolis Colts 24 at Pittsburgh Steelers 26 Mason Rudolph PIT 26/35-191yd 3run-5yd 1td
- 2017-11-12 8y Pittsburgh Steelers 20 at Indianapolis Colts 17 Ben Roethlisberger PIT 19/31-236yd 2run-5yd 2td
- 2016-11-24 9y Pittsburgh Steelers 28 at Indianapolis Colts 7 Ben Roethlisberger PIT 14/20-221yd 3td
- 2015-12-06 10y Indianapolis Colts 19 at Pittsburgh Steelers 23 Ben Roethlisberger PIT 24/39-364yd 1run-13yd 4td
- 2014-10-26 11y Indianapolis Colts 19 at Pittsburgh Steelers 13 Andrew Luck IND 26/45-400yd 3run-26yd 3td
- 2011-09-25 15y Pittsburgh Steelers 23 at Indianapolis Colts 20 Ben Roethlisberger PIT 25/37-364yd 5run-15yd 1td
- 2008-11-09 17y Indianapolis Colts 24 at Pittsburgh Steelers 20 Peyton Manning IND 21/40-240yd 3td
- 2006-01-15 20y Pittsburgh Steelers 21 at Indianapolis Colts 18 Ben Roethlisberger PIT 14/24-197yd 1tck 2td
- 2005-11-28 20y Pittsburgh Steelers 7 at Indianapolis Colts 26 Peyton Manning IND 15/25-245yd 2td
- 2002-10-21 23y Indianapolis Colts 10 at Pittsburgh Steelers 28 Tommy Maddox PIT 15/23-188yd 2td
- 1997-10-12 29y Indianapolis Colts 22 at Pittsburgh Steelers 24
- 1996-12-29 29y Indianapolis Colts 14 at Pittsburgh Steelers 42
- 1996-01-14 30y Indianapolis Colts 16 at Pittsburgh Steelers 20
- 1994-09-18 32y Indianapolis Colts 21 at Pittsburgh Steelers 31
- 1992-11-22 33y Indianapolis Colts 14 at Pittsburgh Steelers 30
- 1991-10-06 35y Pittsburgh Steelers 21 at Indianapolis Colts 3
- 1987-10-18 38y Indianapolis Colts 7 at Pittsburgh Steelers 21
- 1985-09-08 41y Indianapolis Colts 3 at Pittsburgh Steelers 45
- 1984-10-21 41y Pittsburgh Steelers 16 at Indianapolis Colts 17
- 1983-11-13 42y Pittsburgh Steelers 24 at Indianapolis Colts 13
- 1980-09-14 46y Pittsburgh Steelers 20 at Indianapolis Colts 17
- 1979-09-23 47y Indianapolis Colts 13 at Pittsburgh Steelers 17
- 1978-12-09 47y Indianapolis Colts 13 at Pittsburgh Steelers 35
- 1977-10-30 48y Pittsburgh Steelers 21 at Indianapolis Colts 31
- 1976-12-19 49y Pittsburgh Steelers 40 at Indianapolis Colts 14
- 1975-12-27 50y Indianapolis Colts 10 at Pittsburgh Steelers 28
- 1974-09-15 52y Indianapolis Colts 0 at Pittsburgh Steelers 30
- 1971-10-31 54y Pittsburgh Steelers 21 at Indianapolis Colts 34
- 1968-09-29 58y Indianapolis Colts 41 at Pittsburgh Steelers 7
- 1957-11-03 68y Pittsburgh Steelers 19 at Indianapolis Colts 13