- 2026-10-04 1w Indianapolis Colts 30 at Washington Commanders 13 Daniel Jones IND 34/19-143yd 4run-2yd 1td
- 2022-10-30 3y Washington Commanders 17 at Indianapolis Colts 16 Taylor Heinicke WSH 23/31-279yd 6run-29yd 1td 1td
- 2018-09-16 8y Indianapolis Colts 21 at Washington Commanders 9 Andrew Luck IND 21/31-179yd 4run-2yd 2td
- 2014-11-30 11y Washington Commanders 27 at Indianapolis Colts 49 Andrew Luck IND 19/27-370yd 4run-20yd 5td
- 2010-10-17 15y Indianapolis Colts 27 at Washington Commanders 24 Peyton Manning IND 25/38-307yd 2td
- 2006-10-22 19y Washington Commanders 22 at Indianapolis Colts 36 Peyton Manning IND 25/35-342yd 4td
- 2002-10-27 23y Indianapolis Colts 21 at Washington Commanders 26 Shane Matthews WSH 17/35-210yd 3run-10yd 1rec--13yd 2td
- 1999-12-19 26y Washington Commanders 21 at Indianapolis Colts 24
- 1996-10-27 29y Indianapolis Colts 16 at Washington Commanders 31
- 1994-10-23 31y Washington Commanders 41 at Indianapolis Colts 27
- 1993-11-07 32y Indianapolis Colts 24 at Washington Commanders 30
- 1990-12-22 35y Washington Commanders 28 at Indianapolis Colts 35
- 1984-10-07 42y Washington Commanders 35 at Indianapolis Colts 7
- 1981-12-13 44y Indianapolis Colts 14 at Washington Commanders 38
- 1978-11-06 47y Washington Commanders 17 at Indianapolis Colts 21
- 1977-11-07 48y Washington Commanders 3 at Indianapolis Colts 10
- 1973-11-18 52y Indianapolis Colts 14 at Washington Commanders 22
- 1969-11-02 56y Washington Commanders 17 at Indianapolis Colts 41
- 1967-10-29 58y Indianapolis Colts 17 at Washington Commanders 13
- 1966-11-06 59y Washington Commanders 10 at Indianapolis Colts 37
- 1965-10-17 60y Indianapolis Colts 38 at Washington Commanders 7
- 1964-12-13 61y Washington Commanders 17 at Indianapolis Colts 45
- 1963-12-01 62y Indianapolis Colts 36 at Washington Commanders 20
- 1962-12-08 63y Washington Commanders 21 at Indianapolis Colts 34
- 1961-11-26 64y Indianapolis Colts 27 at Washington Commanders 6
- 1960-09-25 66y Washington Commanders 0 at Indianapolis Colts 20
- 1959-11-08 66y Indianapolis Colts 24 at Washington Commanders 27
- 1958-10-26 67y Washington Commanders 10 at Indianapolis Colts 35
- 1957-11-10 68y Indianapolis Colts 21 at Washington Commanders 17
- 1956-12-23 69y Washington Commanders 17 at Indianapolis Colts 19
- 1955-10-23 70y Washington Commanders 14 at Indianapolis Colts 13
- 1954-10-31 71y Indianapolis Colts 21 at Washington Commanders 24
- 1953-10-25 72y Washington Commanders 17 at Indianapolis Colts 27