- 2026-11-29 in 1mo New York Giants at Baltimore Colts
- 2024-12-29 1y Baltimore Colts 33 at New York Giants 45 Drew Lock NYG 17/23-309yd 4td 1td
- 2023-01-01 3y Baltimore Colts 10 at New York Giants 38 Daniel Jones NYG 11run-91yd 2td 2td
- 2018-12-23 7y New York Giants 27 at Baltimore Colts 28 Andrew Luck IND 31/47-357yd 2run-13yd 2td
- 2014-11-03 11y Baltimore Colts 40 at New York Giants 24 Andrew Luck IND 25/46-354yd 2run-5yd 4td
- 2010-09-19 16y New York Giants 14 at Baltimore Colts 38 Peyton Manning IND 20/26-255yd 3td
- 2006-09-10 20y Baltimore Colts 26 at New York Giants 21 Peyton Manning IND 25/41-276yd 1td
- 2002-12-22 23y New York Giants 44 at Baltimore Colts 27 Kerry Collins NYG 23/29-366yd 4td
- 1999-11-14 26y Baltimore Colts 27 at New York Giants 19
- 1993-12-12 32y Baltimore Colts 6 at New York Giants 20
- 1990-11-05 35y New York Giants 24 at Baltimore Colts 7
- 1979-12-16 46y Baltimore Colts 31 at New York Giants 7
- 1975-12-07 50y Baltimore Colts 21 at New York Giants 0
- 1971-10-17 54y Baltimore Colts 31 at New York Giants 7
- 1968-11-03 57y Baltimore Colts 26 at New York Giants 0
- 1963-09-15 63y New York Giants 37 at Baltimore Colts 28
- 1959-12-27 66y New York Giants 16 at Baltimore Colts 31
- 1958-12-28 67y Baltimore Colts 23 at New York Giants 17
- 1958-11-09 67y Baltimore Colts 21 at New York Giants 24
- 1955-11-13 70y Baltimore Colts 7 at New York Giants 17
- 1954-10-02 72y New York Giants 14 at Baltimore Colts 20