Matthew Schaefer’s hat trick powers Islanders past Blue Jackets

ELMONT, N.Y. (Interstat) — Matthew Schaefer recorded a hat trick and the New York Islanders used a three-goal third period to pull away from the Columbus Blue Jackets at UBS Arena on Tuesday. The announced attendance was 14,295. Schaefer finished with three goals, nine shots on goal and one hit, while Ilya Sorokin made 28 saves on 29 shots for New York. The Islanders improved to 10-10 this season, and Columbus fell to 7-12. The game remained tight into the final period before New York’s depth and Schaefer’s finishing touch separated the teams.

Columbus created some early traffic in front of Sorokin, but the Islanders goaltender was sharp from the opening minutes. Sorokin stopped Cole Sillinger on a wrist shot and later denied Jake Christiansen and Erik Gudbranson as the Blue Jackets pushed for the first goal. At the other end, Cam Talbot kept Columbus close by turning aside Kyle Palmieri and Matthew Schaefer during a busy first period. The Islanders broke through late in the opening frame when Anthony Duclair scored on a wrist shot with 58 seconds remaining. Mathew Barzal and Tony DeAngelo assisted on the goal, which gave New York a lead after a period in which both teams traded chances but neither side controlled play for long. Columbus also had to kill a penalty after Cole Sillinger was called for slashing against Emil Heineman.

Schaefer doubled the Islanders’ lead in the second period with an unassisted wrist shot. New York’s forecheck created turnovers and kept Columbus from settling into its defensive structure, and Sorokin continued to handle the Blue Jackets’ best looks. Talbot made saves on Barzal and Bo Horvat as the Islanders pressed for more, while Sorokin denied Charlie Coyle and Cole Sillinger at the other end. Columbus’s penalty kill and Talbot’s goaltending kept the deficit at two goals heading into the third, but the Blue Jackets had generated little sustained offense against New York’s defense. Schaefer’s goal gave the Islanders a 2-0 lead after two periods.

Columbus finally solved Sorokin early in the third period when Zach Werenski scored on a wrist shot. Kent Johnson and Luca Del Bel Belluz assisted on the goal, which cut New York’s lead to one and briefly quieted the home crowd. The Islanders responded quickly. Schaefer restored the two-goal cushion with a backhand, with Ryan Pulock and Duclair assisting. A delay-of-game penalty against Columbus for an unsuccessful challenge followed the goal, and New York kept the pressure on. Tony DeAngelo added another goal later in the period, scoring on a backhand after Barzal and Matias Maccelli set him up. Schaefer then completed his hat trick with a wrist shot, with Simon Holmstrom and Horvat assisting, and the Islanders closed out a convincing home win.

Schaefer’s three-goal, nine-shot performance was the standout. Duclair, a 6-foot, 200-pound forward, finished with a goal and an assist, two shots on goal and one hit. DeAngelo had a goal and an assist with two shots on goal. Barzal recorded two assists and two shots on goal, while Horvat had one assist, four shots on goal and one hit. Pulock added an assist, three shots on goal and one hit, and Maccelli had an assist and three shots on goal. Sorokin, listed at 6-foot-4 and 211 pounds, earned the win with 28 saves. For Columbus, Del Bel Belluz had an assist, one shot on goal and two hits. Werenski scored on one of his three shots and added one hit. The Blue Jackets’ best chances came in spurts, but they could not sustain pressure against New York’s defensive corps.

The Islanders’ victory came after a road trip that included wins at Anaheim and Los Angeles, and it gave them a 10-10 record as they prepare for their next game at Winnipeg. Columbus, which has lost consecutive games, dropped to 7-12 and next plays at Chicago. New York’s penalty kill did not face much stress beyond the first-period slashing call against Columbus, and the Islanders’ even-strength play produced the decisive goals. The Blue Jackets’ goal from Werenski was one of their few clean looks in the third period, and Sorokin was rarely tested after New York regained control.

Interstat’s game simulator had projected a final score of N.Y. Islanders 3, Columbus 1. Interstat’s ELO system had projected N.Y. Islanders with a 53 percent probability to win. N.Y. Islanders had been installed as a pregame favorite with a spread of -1.5. The total score of 6 went under the over/under line of 5.5.