- 2013-01-05 13y Seton Hall Pirates 74 at Notre Dame Fightin` Irish 93 Jack Cooley ND 27m 19p 13r
- 2012-01-25 14y Notre Dame Fightin` Irish 55 at Seton Hall Pirates 42 Jack Cooley ND 34m 13p 11r 2b
- 2011-02-26 15y Seton Hall Pirates 48 at Notre Dame Fightin` Irish 60 Tim Abromaitis ND 40m 22p 8r 2a
- 2010-03-10 16y Notre Dame Fightin` Irish 68 at Seton Hall Pirates 56
- 2010-02-11 16y Notre Dame Fightin` Irish 87 at Seton Hall Pirates 90 Jeremy Hazell SETON 36m 35p 3r 1a
- 2009-01-10 17y Seton Hall Pirates 79 at Notre Dame Fightin` Irish 88 Luke Harangody ND 39m 30p 16r 2a 1b
- 2008-02-06 18y Notre Dame Fightin` Irish 95 at Seton Hall Pirates 69 Luke Harangody ND 33m 22p 13r 4a 1b
- 2007-01-14 19y Seton Hall Pirates 76 at Notre Dame Fightin` Irish 88 Russell Carter ND 31m 24p 10r 3a
- 2006-02-18 20y Notre Dame Fightin` Irish 102 at Seton Hall Pirates 91
- 2005-01-05 21y Notre Dame Fightin` Irish 66 at Seton Hall Pirates 65
- 2004-02-14 22y Seton Hall Pirates 68 at Notre Dame Fightin` Irish 71
- 2003-02-05 23y Notre Dame Fightin` Irish 72 at Seton Hall Pirates 78
- 2003-01-12 23y Seton Hall Pirates 64 at Notre Dame Fightin` Irish 74
- 2002-02-03 24y Notre Dame Fightin` Irish 63 at Seton Hall Pirates 61
- 2002-01-26 24y Seton Hall Pirates 51 at Notre Dame Fightin` Irish 60
- 2001-02-18 25y Seton Hall Pirates 74 at Notre Dame Fightin` Irish 64
- 2001-01-08 25y Notre Dame Fightin` Irish 76 at Seton Hall Pirates 78
- 2000-02-19 26y Notre Dame Fightin` Irish 76 at Seton Hall Pirates 74
- 1999-03-03 27y Notre Dame Fightin` Irish 69 at Seton Hall Pirates 79
- 1999-02-06 27y Notre Dame Fightin` Irish 76 at Seton Hall Pirates 60
- 1999-01-19 27y Seton Hall Pirates 56 at Notre Dame Fightin` Irish 59
- 1998-01-17 28y Notre Dame Fightin` Irish 58 at Seton Hall Pirates 64
- 1997-02-18 29y Notre Dame Fightin` Irish 74 at Seton Hall Pirates 85
- 1997-01-22 29y Seton Hall Pirates 72 at Notre Dame Fightin` Irish 86
- 1996-02-24 30y Seton Hall Pirates 60 at Notre Dame Fightin` Irish 72