- 2027-02-17 in 3mo Plymouth State Panthers at Castleton Spartans
- 2027-01-07 in 1mo Castleton Spartans at Plymouth State Panthers
- 2026-02-18 8mo Castleton Spartans 51 at Plymouth State Panthers 64
- 2026-01-08 10mo Plymouth State Panthers 83 at Castleton Spartans 75
- 2025-02-12 1y Plymouth State Panthers 71 at Castleton Spartans 67 Kevin Henry PLYST 38m 32p 5r 1a 1b
- 2025-01-14 1y Castleton Spartans 64 at Plymouth State Panthers 90 Elijah Swanson PLYST 24m 12p 5r 3a 1b
- 2023-02-01 3y Plymouth State Panthers 71 at Castleton Spartans 69 Giorgi Tsiklauri PLYST 31m 15p 11r 3a
- 2023-01-11 3y Castleton Spartans 58 at Plymouth State Panthers 70 Kyler Bosse PLYST 37m 28p 11r 4a 2b
- 2022-02-07 4y Plymouth State Panthers 88 at Castleton Spartans 51 Manny Alisandro PLYST 26m 12p 9r 2a
- 2022-02-02 4y Castleton Spartans 33 at Plymouth State Panthers 64 Kyler Bosse PLYST 19m 12p 6r 1a
- 2020-02-19 6y Castleton Spartans 49 at Plymouth State Panthers 69 Devin Cooper PLYST 26m 18p 10r 2b
- 2020-01-09 6y Plymouth State Panthers 74 at Castleton Spartans 50 Manny Alisandro PLYST 32m 16p 11r 1a
- 2019-01-19 7y Castleton Spartans 49 at Plymouth State Panthers 82 Dante Rivera PLYST 33m 34p 3r 4a
- 2018-11-28 7y Plymouth State Panthers 87 at Castleton Spartans 76 Dante Rivera PLYST 35m 12p 5r 7a
- 2017-11-21 8y Castleton Spartans 100 at Plymouth State Panthers 93 Jordan Nelson CASTL 21m 18p 6r 3a
- 2016-11-22 9y Plymouth State Panthers 50 at Castleton Spartans 52 Edmund Fitzgerald CASTL 35m 11p 13r 3a 2b
- 2015-11-24 10y Castleton Spartans 71 at Plymouth State Panthers 88 Curtis Arsenault PLYST 32m 18p 9r 2a 1b
- 2014-11-25 11y Plymouth State Panthers 70 at Castleton Spartans 75 Chad Copeland CASTL 39m 31p 11r 1b
- 2013-11-26 12y Castleton Spartans 80 at Plymouth State Panthers 83 Uche Nwokeji PLYST 27m 19p 16r 1a
- 2012-11-20 13y Plymouth State Panthers 89 at Castleton Spartans 95 Mark Comstock CASTL 26m 20p 8r 6a
- 2011-11-22 14y Castleton Spartans 93 at Plymouth State Panthers 91 Greg Hughes CASTL 22m 24p 4r 2a