- 2027-01-23 in 2mo Washington & Jefferson Presidents at Allegheny Gators
- 2026-01-24 9mo Allegheny Gators 72 at Washington & Jefferson Presidents 85 Nathan Plotner WASHJ 31m 18p 4r 3b
- 2025-02-12 1y Allegheny Gators 68 at Washington & Jefferson Presidents 90 Nathan Plotner WASHJ 28m 18p 14r 1a 3b
- 2025-01-04 1y Washington & Jefferson Presidents 81 at Allegheny Gators 87 Luke Barker ALLG 37m 27p 3r 3a
- 2024-02-17 2y Allegheny Gators 91 at Washington & Jefferson Presidents 96 Nick Gearhart WASHJ 30m 21p 6r 4a 2b
- 2024-01-13 2y Washington & Jefferson Presidents 109 at Allegheny Gators 86 Alex Acosta WASHJ 28m 34p 9r 3b
- 2023-02-01 3y Allegheny Gators 63 at Washington & Jefferson Presidents 65 Kyran Mitchell WASHJ 30m 10p 7r 5a 1b
- 2022-12-07 3y Washington & Jefferson Presidents 84 at Allegheny Gators 90 Luke Barker ALLG 35m 32p 10r 2a 1b
- 2017-11-18 8y Washington & Jefferson Presidents 54 at Allegheny Gators 75 Jordan Rawls ALLG 28m 23p 11r 1a 1b