- 2027-01-27 in 3mo West Liberty Hilltoppers at Davis & Elkins Senators
- 2026-12-12 in 1mo Davis & Elkins Senators at West Liberty Hilltoppers
- 2026-03-06 7mo Davis & Elkins Senators 74 at West Liberty Hilltoppers 84
- 2026-02-04 8mo Davis & Elkins Senators 74 at West Liberty Hilltoppers 111
- 2026-01-03 9mo West Liberty Hilltoppers 101 at Davis & Elkins Senators 97
- 2025-03-07 1y Davis & Elkins Senators 77 at West Liberty Hilltoppers 102 Daniel Autrey WLIB 16m 25p 1r
- 2025-02-05 1y West Liberty Hilltoppers 78 at Davis & Elkins Senators 66 Finley Woodward WLIB 28m 14p 4r 2a 1b
- 2024-12-07 1y Davis & Elkins Senators 93 at West Liberty Hilltoppers 107 Daniel Autrey WLIB 10m 10p 3r 1a
- 2024-02-07 2y Davis & Elkins Senators 75 at West Liberty Hilltoppers 95 Christian Montague WLIB 26m 12p 4r 4a 1b
- 2023-12-02 2y West Liberty Hilltoppers 91 at Davis & Elkins Senators 85 Finley Woodward WLIB 24m 16p 9r 3a
- 2023-01-25 3y Davis & Elkins Senators 69 at West Liberty Hilltoppers 104 Bryce Butler WLIB 23m 20p 10r 4a 1b
- 2022-12-03 3y West Liberty Hilltoppers 101 at Davis & Elkins Senators 64 Bryce Butler WLIB 26m 21p 4r 4a
- 2022-01-26 4y West Liberty Hilltoppers 90 at Davis & Elkins Senators 63 Bryce Butler WLIB 27m 17p 7r 3a 1b
- 2021-12-04 4y Davis & Elkins Senators 69 at West Liberty Hilltoppers 100 Bryce Butler WLIB 26m 23p 10r 4a
- 2021-02-22 5y West Liberty Hilltoppers 77 at Davis & Elkins Senators 59 Bryce Butler WLIB 26m 16p 7r 1a
- 2020-01-29 6y Davis & Elkins Senators 73 at West Liberty Hilltoppers 100 Dalton Bolon WLIB 26m 16p 11r 3a
- 2019-12-07 6y West Liberty Hilltoppers 103 at Davis & Elkins Senators 73 Pat Robinson WLIB 24m 21p 6r 2a
- 2017-11-14 8y West Liberty Hilltoppers 123 at Davis & Elkins Senators 90 Dalton Bolon WLIB 28m 26p 4r 3a
- 2016-11-16 9y Davis & Elkins Senators 74 at West Liberty Hilltoppers 87 Devin Hoehn WLIB 35m 27p 4r 7a
- 2013-01-03 13y West Liberty Hilltoppers 120 at Davis & Elkins Senators 61 Alex Falk WLIB 18m 17p 3r 4a
- 2012-02-25 14y Davis & Elkins Senators 81 at West Liberty Hilltoppers 112 Keene Cockburn WLIB 29m 13p 12r 3a
- 2012-01-23 14y West Liberty Hilltoppers 108 at Davis & Elkins Senators 87 Alex Falk WLIB 28m 18p 6r 5a