- 2025-07-05 1y San Jose Earthquakes 1 at New York Red Bulls 1
- 2025-07-05 1y New York Red Bulls 1 at San Jose Earthquakes 1
- 2025-02-08 1y New York Red Bulls 1 at San Jose Earthquakes 0
- 2023-04-08 3y San Jose Earthquakes 1 at New York Red Bulls 1
- 2023-02-18 3y San Jose Earthquakes 0 at New York Red Bulls 2
- 2022-02-26 4y New York Red Bulls 3 at San Jose Earthquakes 1 Omir Guadalupe Fernandez Mosso USA-NENV 77min 1g
- 2019-03-16 7y San Jose Earthquakes 1 at New York Red Bulls 4 Daniel Royer USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 2018-10-06 8y New York Red Bulls 3 at San Jose Earthquakes 1 Aaron Long USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 2017-07-19 9y San Jose Earthquakes 1 at New York Red Bulls 5 Sacha Klještan USA-NENV 79min 1g
- 2016-04-13 10y New York Red Bulls 0 at San Jose Earthquakes 2 Abdul-Fatai Alashe USA-SJHT 90min 1g
- 2015-04-17 11y San Jose Earthquakes 0 at New York Red Bulls 2 Sacha Klještan USA-NENV 86min 1g
- 2014-07-19 12y San Jose Earthquakes 1 at New York Red Bulls 1
- 2013-03-10 13y New York Red Bulls 1 at San Jose Earthquakes 2 Chris Elliott Wondolowski USA-SJHT 90min 1g yc
- 2012-04-14 14y San Jose Earthquakes 2 at New York Red Bulls 2
- 2011-07-02 15y New York Red Bulls 2 at San Jose Earthquakes 2
- 2011-04-16 15y San Jose Earthquakes 0 at New York Red Bulls 3 Thierry Henry USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 2010-11-04 15y San Jose Earthquakes 3 at New York Red Bulls 1 Bobby Convey USA-SJHT 90min 2g 1a
- 2010-10-30 15y New York Red Bulls 1 at San Jose Earthquakes 0 Joel Lindpere USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 2010-08-28 16y San Jose Earthquakes 0 at New York Red Bulls 2 Dane Richards USA-NENV 90min 1g yc
- 2010-05-08 16y New York Red Bulls 0 at San Jose Earthquakes 4 Ryan David Johnson USA-SJHT 85min 1g
- 2009-10-03 17y New York Red Bulls 0 at San Jose Earthquakes 1 Ryan David Johnson USA-SJHT 90min 1g
- 2009-05-08 17y San Jose Earthquakes 1 at New York Red Bulls 4 Macoumba Kandji USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 2008-07-27 18y New York Red Bulls 1 at San Jose Earthquakes 1
- 2008-04-27 18y San Jose Earthquakes 0 at New York Red Bulls 2 Jon Conway USA-NENV 90min
- 2005-07-22 21y New York Red Bulls 1 at San Jose Earthquakes 2 Dwayne De Rosario USA-SJHT 90min 1g
- 2005-05-06 21y San Jose Earthquakes 1 at New York Red Bulls 0 Ronald Cerritos USA-SJHT 80min (sub in 10) 1g
- 2004-07-09 22y San Jose Earthquakes 0 at New York Red Bulls 2 Amado Guevara USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 2004-06-11 22y New York Red Bulls 1 at San Jose Earthquakes 3 Jeff Agoos USA-SJHT 90min 1g
- 2004-05-07 22y New York Red Bulls 5 at San Jose Earthquakes 5
- 2003-10-04 23y New York Red Bulls 2 at San Jose Earthquakes 0 Steve Jolley USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 2003-07-01 23y San Jose Earthquakes 4 at New York Red Bulls 4
- 2002-05-10 24y New York Red Bulls 1 at San Jose Earthquakes 2 Ariel José Graziani Lentini USA-SJHT 86min 2g
- 2002-04-26 24y San Jose Earthquakes 1 at New York Red Bulls 1
- 2001-06-15 25y San Jose Earthquakes 0 at New York Red Bulls 0
- 2001-05-18 25y New York Red Bulls 0 at San Jose Earthquakes 2 Wade Barrett USA-SJHT 90min 1g
- 2000-06-27 26y San Jose Earthquakes 0 at New York Red Bulls 0
- 2000-04-07 26y New York Red Bulls 0 at San Jose Earthquakes 2 John Joseph Doyle USA-SJHT 90min 2g
- 1999-09-21 27y San Jose Earthquakes 2 at New York Red Bulls 1 Dario Brose USA-SJHT 90min 1g
- 1999-08-27 27y New York Red Bulls 1 at San Jose Earthquakes 1 Billy Walsh USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 1998-08-08 28y New York Red Bulls 1 at San Jose Earthquakes 5 Victor Hugo Mella González USA-SJHT 90min 1g
- 1998-04-24 28y San Jose Earthquakes 3 at New York Red Bulls 4 Panayotis Alexander Lalas USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 1997-09-05 29y New York Red Bulls 0 at San Jose Earthquakes 4 Lawrence Lozzano USA-SJHT 90min 1g
- 1997-08-28 29y San Jose Earthquakes 0 at New York Red Bulls 3 Roberto Donadoni USA-NENV 68min 1g
- 1997-05-08 29y San Jose Earthquakes 1 at New York Red Bulls 0 Lawrence Lozzano USA-SJHT 90min 1g yc
- 1997-03-21 29y New York Red Bulls 0 at San Jose Earthquakes 0 Tony Meola USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 1996-07-27 30y San Jose Earthquakes 1 at New York Red Bulls 4 Rob Johnson USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 1996-07-23 30y New York Red Bulls 1 at San Jose Earthquakes 0 Rob Johnson USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 1996-06-15 30y San Jose Earthquakes 1 at New York Red Bulls 0 Jeff Baicher USA-SJHT 57min 1g