- 2025-02-12 1y San Jose Earthquakes 1 at Chicago Fire 5
- 2022-07-03 4y Chicago Fire 1 at San Jose Earthquakes 2 Benjamin Kikanovic USA-SJHT 90min 2g yc
- 2020-07-19 6y San Jose Earthquakes 2 at Chicago Fire 0 Cristian Omar Espinoza USA-SANJ 82min 1g
- 2019-05-18 7y Chicago Fire 1 at San Jose Earthquakes 4 Chris Elliott Wondolowski USA-SJHT 90min 4g
- 2018-06-02 8y San Jose Earthquakes 1 at Chicago Fire 2 Aleksandar Katai USA-CHRU 90min 1g
- 2017-09-27 9y Chicago Fire 4 at San Jose Earthquakes 1 Luis Emilio Lucho Solignac USA-CHRU 90min 1g
- 2016-07-01 10y San Jose Earthquakes 0 at Chicago Fire 1 John Goossens USA-CHRU 79min 1g
- 2015-03-22 11y Chicago Fire 1 at San Jose Earthquakes 2 Robert Tyrel Harden USA-SJHT 90min 1g
- 2014-07-23 12y Chicago Fire 1 at San Jose Earthquakes 5 Chris Elliott Wondolowski USA-SJHT 90min 1g
- 2013-07-03 13y San Jose Earthquakes 2 at Chicago Fire 3 Dilly Duka USA-CHRU 87min 1g
- 2012-07-28 14y Chicago Fire 1 at San Jose Earthquakes 1
- 2011-09-10 15y Chicago Fire 0 at San Jose Earthquakes 2 Chris Elliott Wondolowski USA-SJHT 90min 1g
- 2011-05-28 15y San Jose Earthquakes 2 at Chicago Fire 2
- 2010-09-29 16y Chicago Fire 3 at San Jose Earthquakes 0 Karl Fredrik Ljungberg USA-CHRU 90min 1g
- 2010-04-10 16y San Jose Earthquakes 2 at Chicago Fire 1 Ike Opara USA-SJHT 90min 1g
- 2009-07-18 17y San Jose Earthquakes 0 at Chicago Fire 2 Patrick Nyarko USA-CHIC 90min 1g
- 2009-04-11 17y Chicago Fire 3 at San Jose Earthquakes 3
- 2008-06-28 18y San Jose Earthquakes 0 at Chicago Fire 0
- 2008-04-12 18y Chicago Fire 1 at San Jose Earthquakes 0 Chad Barrett USA-CHRU 61min 1g
- 2005-09-20 21y Chicago Fire 0 at San Jose Earthquakes 2 Dwayne De Rosario USA-SJHT 90min 2g yc
- 2005-04-15 21y San Jose Earthquakes 1 at Chicago Fire 2 Thiago da Rosa Corrêa USA-CHIC 89min 1g yc
- 2004-08-10 22y San Jose Earthquakes 1 at Chicago Fire 2 Damani Ralph USA-CHRU 90min 1g
- 2004-06-18 22y San Jose Earthquakes 1 at Chicago Fire 1
- 2004-04-09 22y Chicago Fire 0 at San Jose Earthquakes 0
- 2003-11-22 22y Chicago Fire 2 at San Jose Earthquakes 4 Landon Donovan USA-SJHT 90min 2g
- 2003-07-04 23y Chicago Fire 0 at San Jose Earthquakes 0
- 2003-05-30 23y Chicago Fire 4 at San Jose Earthquakes 1 DaMarcus Beasley USA-CHRU 90min 2g
- 2003-05-09 23y San Jose Earthquakes 0 at Chicago Fire 0
- 2002-07-23 24y Chicago Fire 0 at San Jose Earthquakes 1 Ariel José Graziani Lentini USA-SJHT 80min 1g
- 2002-05-25 24y San Jose Earthquakes 1 at Chicago Fire 1
- 2001-08-17 25y Chicago Fire 1 at San Jose Earthquakes 0 Jesse Marsch USA-CHRU 90min 1g yc
- 2001-05-25 25y San Jose Earthquakes 1 at Chicago Fire 1
- 2000-06-23 26y Chicago Fire 1 at San Jose Earthquakes 1
- 2000-05-12 26y San Jose Earthquakes 1 at Chicago Fire 4 Lubos Kubik USA-CHIC 81min 1g yc
- 1999-09-25 27y Chicago Fire 0 at San Jose Earthquakes 2 Ronald Cerritos USA-SJHT 90min 1g
- 1999-07-22 27y San Jose Earthquakes 2 at Chicago Fire 2 Joshua David Wolff USA-CHIC 90min 1g
- 1999-06-18 27y San Jose Earthquakes 0 at Chicago Fire 2 Lubos Kubik USA-CHIC 90min 1g
- 1999-03-19 27y Chicago Fire 3 at San Jose Earthquakes 1 Ante Razov USA-CHIC 90min 2g
- 1998-08-14 28y San Jose Earthquakes 1 at Chicago Fire 2 Roman Kosecki USA-CHRU 90min 1g
- 1998-07-28 28y Chicago Fire 0 at San Jose Earthquakes 3 Braeden Cloutier USA-SJHT 90min 1g
- 1998-06-10 28y San Jose Earthquakes 2 at Chicago Fire 5 Piotr Nowak USA-CHRU 72min 2g
- 1998-04-10 28y Chicago Fire 0 at San Jose Earthquakes 1 Ronald Cerritos USA-SJHT 90min 1g