- 2022-08-02 4y Colorado Rapids 5 at New York Red Bulls 4 Keegan Rosenberry USA-COUG 90min 1g
- 2019-08-31 7y Colorado Rapids 2 at New York Red Bulls 0 Jonathan Jeremy Lewis USA-COUG 89min 2g
- 2018-05-12 8y New York Red Bulls 2 at Colorado Rapids 1 Daniel Royer USA-NEWY 90min 1g
- 2017-03-11 9y Colorado Rapids 0 at New York Red Bulls 1 Luis Robles USA-NENV 90min
- 2016-04-16 10y New York Red Bulls 1 at Colorado Rapids 2 Jermaine Jones USA-COUG 90min 1g
- 2015-04-29 11y Colorado Rapids 1 at New York Red Bulls 1
- 2014-03-15 12y Colorado Rapids 1 at New York Red Bulls 1
- 2013-07-04 13y New York Red Bulls 0 at Colorado Rapids 2 Nathan Sturgis USA-COUG 90min 1g
- 2012-03-25 14y Colorado Rapids 1 at New York Red Bulls 4 Thierry Henry USA-NENV 90min 2g
- 2011-07-20 15y New York Red Bulls 1 at Colorado Rapids 4 Sanna Nyassi USA-COUG 86min 3g
- 2011-05-25 15y Colorado Rapids 2 at New York Red Bulls 2
- 2010-09-11 16y Colorado Rapids 1 at New York Red Bulls 3 Timothy Michael Ream USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 2010-07-04 16y New York Red Bulls 1 at Colorado Rapids 1
- 2009-07-25 17y New York Red Bulls 0 at Colorado Rapids 4 Mehdi Ballouchy USA-COUG 90min 1g
- 2009-05-30 17y Colorado Rapids 3 at New York Red Bulls 2 Conor Casey USA-COUG 90min 2g
- 2008-09-27 18y Colorado Rapids 5 at New York Red Bulls 4 Conor Casey USA-COUG 90min 3g yc
- 2008-07-04 18y New York Red Bulls 0 at Colorado Rapids 4 Colin Clark USA-COUG 90min 1g
- 2007-07-07 19y New York Red Bulls 1 at Colorado Rapids 0 John Wolyniec USA-NENV 71min 1g
- 2007-05-13 19y Colorado Rapids 1 at New York Red Bulls 0 Nicolás Hernández USA-COUG 90min 1g
- 2006-10-06 20y New York Red Bulls 1 at Colorado Rapids 1
- 2006-07-13 20y Colorado Rapids 0 at New York Red Bulls 1 Amado Guevara USA-NEWY 90min 1g
- 2005-07-15 21y Colorado Rapids 1 at New York Red Bulls 1
- 2005-04-29 21y New York Red Bulls 3 at Colorado Rapids 1 Amado Guevara USA-NEWY 90min 3g
- 2004-08-20 22y New York Red Bulls 0 at Colorado Rapids 1 Jordan Cila USA-COUG 90min 1g yc
- 2004-06-29 22y Colorado Rapids 3 at New York Red Bulls 2 Nat Borchers USA-COUG 90min 1g
- 2003-07-25 23y New York Red Bulls 0 at Colorado Rapids 1 Mark Chung USA-COUG 90min 1g
- 2003-05-16 23y New York Red Bulls 2 at Colorado Rapids 0 Clint Mathis USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 2003-05-02 23y Colorado Rapids 1 at New York Red Bulls 2 Craig Ziadie USA-NENV 90min 1g yc
- 2002-06-25 24y Colorado Rapids 1 at New York Red Bulls 0 Carlos Alberto Valderrama Palacio USA-COUG 90min 1a
- 2002-04-12 24y New York Red Bulls 2 at Colorado Rapids 1 Brian Kamler USA-NENV 71min 1g
- 2001-05-15 25y Colorado Rapids 0 at New York Red Bulls 1 Alex Comas USA-NENV 46min 1g
- 2001-04-13 25y New York Red Bulls 1 at Colorado Rapids 1
- 2000-08-19 26y Colorado Rapids 3 at New York Red Bulls 5 Mark Chung USA-NEWY 90min 1g
- 2000-06-23 26y New York Red Bulls 3 at Colorado Rapids 1 Steve Jolley USA-NEWY 90min 1g
- 1999-06-11 27y Colorado Rapids 1 at New York Red Bulls 0 Jorge Luis Dely Valdés USA-COUG 90min 1g
- 1999-05-21 27y New York Red Bulls 0 at Colorado Rapids 2 Paul Bravo USA-COUG 81min 2g
- 1998-08-17 28y Colorado Rapids 1 at New York Red Bulls 4 Tabaré Ramos Ricciardi USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 1998-07-03 28y New York Red Bulls 0 at Colorado Rapids 1 Marquis White USA-COUG 20min 1g
- 1997-08-14 29y New York Red Bulls 0 at Colorado Rapids 2 Wolde Harris USA-COLI 90min 1g
- 1997-07-12 29y Colorado Rapids 1 at New York Red Bulls 4 Anthony William de Ávila Charris USA-NEWY 90min 2g
- 1997-06-12 29y Colorado Rapids 3 at New York Red Bulls 1 Peter Vermes USA-COLI 90min 1g
- 1996-08-10 30y New York Red Bulls 2 at Colorado Rapids 0 Roberto Donadoni USA-NENV 90min 1g
- 1996-07-03 30y New York Red Bulls 1 at Colorado Rapids 2 Steve Trittschuh USA-COUG 90min 1g
- 1996-05-15 30y Colorado Rapids 0 at New York Red Bulls 3 Giovanni Savarese Rubinaccio USA-NENV 90min 3g