- 2026-10-31 2w DC United 0 at Columbus Crew 3
- 2025-07-19 1y DC United 1 at Columbus Crew 2
- 2025-03-29 1y Columbus Crew 2 at DC United 1
- 2024-04-06 2y DC United 1 at Columbus Crew 1
- 2023-04-08 3y Columbus Crew 2 at DC United 0 Jacen Russell-Rowe USA-COKE 0min
- 2023-03-04 3y DC United 0 at Columbus Crew 2 Alexandru Irinel Mățan USA-COKE 81min 1a
- 2022-07-13 4y Columbus Crew 2 at DC United 2
- 2022-04-30 4y DC United 0 at Columbus Crew 3 Pedro Miguel Martins Santos USA-COKE 90min 1g
- 2021-10-30 5y Columbus Crew 3 at DC United 1 Lucas Manuel Zelarayán USA-COKE 83min 2g
- 2021-08-04 5y DC United 4 at Columbus Crew 2 José Yordy Reyna Serna USA-DCJH 80min 2g
- 2021-05-08 5y DC United 1 at Columbus Crew 3 Eloy Victor Room USA-COKE 90min
- 2020-10-28 6y Columbus Crew 0 at DC United 1 Julian Gressel USA-DCJH 90min 1g
- 2019-05-04 7y Columbus Crew 1 at DC United 3 Bilal Abdul Hamid USA-DCJH 90min 1g
- 2019-04-24 7y DC United 1 at Columbus Crew 0 Wayne Mark Rooney USA-DCJH 90min 1g
- 2018-11-01 8y Columbus Crew 2 at DC United 2 Federico Fernando Higuaín USA-COLU 90min 2g yc
- 2018-04-14 8y Columbus Crew 0 at DC United 1 Ulises Antonio Segura Machado USA-DCUN 90min 1g
- 2018-03-24 8y DC United 1 at Columbus Crew 3 Pedro Miguel Martins Santos USA-COLU 90min 1g
- 2017-09-30 9y DC United 0 at Columbus Crew 2 Josh Williams USA-COKE 90min 1g
- 2017-03-18 9y Columbus Crew 2 at DC United 0 Federico Fernando Higuaín USA-COKE 90min 1g
- 2016-09-28 10y Columbus Crew 0 at DC United 3 Lloyd Ekow Sam USA-DCJH 72min 1g
- 2016-07-16 10y DC United 1 at Columbus Crew 1
- 2015-10-25 11y DC United 0 at Columbus Crew 5 Ethan Christopher Finlay USA-COKE 90min 2g
- 2015-09-19 11y Columbus Crew 2 at DC United 1 Kaiansu Kei Kamara USA-COKE 90min 1g
- 2015-05-02 11y Columbus Crew 0 at DC United 2 Edgar Fabián Espíndola USA-DCJH 86min 1g yc
- 2014-06-07 12y Columbus Crew 0 at DC United 0
- 2014-04-19 12y DC United 1 at Columbus Crew 1
- 2014-03-08 12y Columbus Crew 3 at DC United 0 Federico Fernando Higuaín USA-COKE 90min 2g yc
- 2013-04-27 13y DC United 0 at Columbus Crew 3 Federico Fernando Higuaín USA-COKE 90min 1g
- 2013-03-23 13y Columbus Crew 2 at DC United 1 Josh Williams USA-COKE 90min 1g
- 2012-10-20 14y Columbus Crew 2 at DC United 3 Marcelo Saragosa USA-DCJH 90min 1g
- 2012-08-04 14y Columbus Crew 0 at DC United 1 Chris Pontius USA-DCJH 90min 1g
- 2012-07-21 14y DC United 0 at Columbus Crew 1 Christopher Birchall USA-COKE 90min 1g
- 2011-10-02 15y DC United 1 at Columbus Crew 2 Eddie Gaven USA-COKE 90min 1g
- 2011-03-19 15y Columbus Crew 1 at DC United 3 Charlie Davies USA-DCJH 38min 2g
- 2010-09-04 16y Columbus Crew 1 at DC United 0 Guillermo Barros Schelotto USA-COKE 90min 1g
- 2010-09-02 16y Columbus Crew 2 at DC United 1 Guillermo Barros Schelotto USA-COKE 90min 1g
- 2010-06-26 16y DC United 0 at Columbus Crew 2 Guillermo Barros Schelotto USA-COKE 90min 1g
- 2009-10-17 17y Columbus Crew 0 at DC United 1 Luciano Emílio da Silva USA-DCJH 90min 1g
- 2009-07-04 17y DC United 1 at Columbus Crew 1
- 2008-10-26 18y DC United 0 at Columbus Crew 1 Brad Evans USA-COKE 84min 1g yc
- 2008-04-17 18y Columbus Crew 2 at DC United 1 Alejandro Enrique Moreno Riera USA-COKE 90min 1g
- 2007-10-20 19y Columbus Crew 3 at DC United 2 Robbie Rogers USA-COKE 90min 2g
- 2007-08-18 19y DC United 2 at Columbus Crew 0 Helbert Frederico Carreiro Da Silva USA-DCJH 90min 1g
- 2007-04-27 19y DC United 0 at Columbus Crew 1 Ezra Hendrickson USA-COKE 90min 1g yc
- 2006-07-14 20y Columbus Crew 2 at DC United 3 Brian Carroll USA-DCUN 90min 1g
- 2006-07-07 20y DC United 1 at Columbus Crew 0 Alecko Eskandarian USA-DCUN 90min 1g
- 2006-05-30 20y Columbus Crew 1 at DC United 5 Joshua Gros USA-DCUN 90min 1g
- 2006-05-19 20y DC United 1 at Columbus Crew 1
- 2005-10-14 21y Columbus Crew 2 at DC United 2
- 2005-07-01 21y DC United 1 at Columbus Crew 0 Nick Rimando USA-DCJH 90min