- 2024-05-11 2y Sheffield Utd 0 at Everton 1 Abdoulaye Doucouré ENG-EVER 90min
- 2023-09-02 3y Everton 2 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 2021-05-16 5y Sheffield Utd 1 at Everton 0 Daniel David Jebbison WOR-SHEF 90min 1g
- 2020-12-26 5y Everton 1 at Sheffield Utd 0 Gylfi Þór Sigurðsson ENG-EVFJ 90min 1g
- 2020-07-20 6y Everton 1 at Sheffield Utd 0 Richarlison de Andrade ENG-EVFJ 90min 1g yc
- 2011-08-25 15y Sheffield Utd 1 at Everton 3 Marouane Fellaini-Bakkioui ENG-EVFJ 90min yc
- 2007-03-03 19y Everton 1 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 2006-10-21 20y Sheffield Utd 0 at Everton 2 Mikel Arteta Amatriain ENG-EVFJ 90min 1g
- 1993-12-10 32y Everton 0 at Sheffield Utd 0
- 1993-05-03 33y Sheffield Utd 2 at Everton 0
- 1992-12-11 33y Everton 0 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1992-04-10 34y Sheffield Utd 2 at Everton 0
- 1991-09-13 35y Everton 1 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 1976-02-07 50y Everton 0 at Sheffield Utd 0
- 1975-08-26 51y Sheffield Utd 0 at Everton 3
- 1975-04-19 51y Sheffield Utd 3 at Everton 2
- 1974-10-12 52y Everton 2 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 1974-02-02 52y Everton 1 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1973-12-15 52y Sheffield Utd 1 at Everton 1
- 1973-03-17 53y Sheffield Utd 1 at Everton 2
- 1972-10-21 54y Everton 1 at Sheffield Utd 0
- 1972-03-18 54y Everton 1 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1971-08-21 55y Sheffield Utd 1 at Everton 0
- 1968-04-13 58y Everton 1 at Sheffield Utd 0
- 1967-01-14 59y Sheffield Utd 1 at Everton 4
- 1966-04-09 60y Sheffield Utd 3 at Everton 1
- 1965-11-13 61y Everton 0 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 1965-01-16 61y Everton 0 at Sheffield Utd 0
- 1964-02-22 62y Everton 0 at Sheffield Utd 0
- 1963-10-15 63y Sheffield Utd 1 at Everton 4
- 1963-03-30 63y Everton 1 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 1962-11-24 63y Sheffield Utd 0 at Everton 3
- 1962-03-14 64y Everton 1 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1956-04-02 70y Everton 1 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1956-03-30 70y Sheffield Utd 4 at Everton 1
- 1949-04-09 77y Everton 1 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1948-11-13 78y Sheffield Utd 1 at Everton 2
- 1948-03-20 78y Everton 1 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 1947-11-01 79y Sheffield Utd 0 at Everton 2
- 1947-04-19 79y Everton 0 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 1946-12-14 79y Sheffield Utd 3 at Everton 2
- 1934-03-24 92y Sheffield Utd 0 at Everton 4
- 1933-11-11 93y Everton 1 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1933-05-03 93y Sheffield Utd 0 at Everton 1
- 1932-12-17 93y Everton 2 at Sheffield Utd 3
- 1932-02-20 94y Sheffield Utd 1 at Everton 5
- 1931-10-10 95y Everton 5 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1930-04-26 96y Sheffield Utd 2 at Everton 3
- 1929-12-21 96y Everton 0 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 1929-03-30 97y Sheffield Utd 3 at Everton 1