- 1996-01-24 30y Grimsby Town 0 at Sunderland 1
- 1994-08-30 32y Grimsby Town 2 at Sunderland 2
- 1994-04-12 32y Sunderland 1 at Grimsby Town 0
- 1993-09-28 33y Grimsby Town 2 at Sunderland 2
- 1948-01-03 78y Sunderland 2 at Grimsby Town 1
- 1947-08-30 79y Grimsby Town 2 at Sunderland 4
- 1947-05-10 79y Sunderland 2 at Grimsby Town 1
- 1946-10-19 80y Grimsby Town 2 at Sunderland 1
- 1938-12-31 87y Sunderland 3 at Grimsby Town 1
- 1938-03-29 88y Sunderland 2 at Grimsby Town 0
- 1937-11-13 88y Grimsby Town 2 at Sunderland 2
- 1937-04-12 89y Sunderland 0 at Grimsby Town 6
- 1936-12-05 89y Grimsby Town 1 at Sunderland 5
- 1936-02-19 90y Grimsby Town 1 at Sunderland 3
- 1935-10-12 91y Sunderland 0 at Grimsby Town 4
- 1934-09-05 92y Grimsby Town 0 at Sunderland 3
- 1934-08-28 92y Sunderland 0 at Grimsby Town 0
- 1932-04-16 94y Grimsby Town 0 at Sunderland 2
- 1931-12-05 94y Sunderland 3 at Grimsby Town 1
- 1931-03-24 95y Sunderland 1 at Grimsby Town 2
- 1930-03-29 96y Grimsby Town 0 at Sunderland 2
- 1929-11-23 96y Sunderland 1 at Grimsby Town 0
- 1903-01-24 123y Sunderland 4 at Grimsby Town 2
- 1902-09-27 124y Grimsby Town 1 at Sunderland 5
- 1902-03-22 124y Grimsby Town 1 at Sunderland 3
- 1901-11-23 124y Sunderland 3 at Grimsby Town 3