- 2022-01-15 4y Watford FC 1 at Newcastle United FC 1
- 2021-09-25 5y Newcastle United FC 1 at Watford FC 1
- 2020-07-11 6y Newcastle United FC 1 at Watford FC 2 Troy Deeney ENG-WAXQ 85min 2g
- 2019-01-26 7y Watford FC 2 at Newcastle United FC 0 Andre Gray ENG-WAXQ 68min 1g
- 2018-12-29 7y Newcastle United FC 1 at Watford FC 1
- 2018-11-03 7y Watford FC 0 at Newcastle United FC 1 Ayoze Pérez Gutiérrez ENG-NEJP 45min 1g
- 2018-05-05 8y Newcastle United FC 1 at Watford FC 2 Roberto Maximiliano Pereyra ENG-WAXQ 56min 1g
- 2017-11-25 8y Watford FC 3 at Newcastle United FC 0 Andre Gray ENG-WAXQ 90min 1g
- 2016-01-23 10y Newcastle United FC 1 at Watford FC 2 Odion Jude Ighalo ENG-WAXQ 90min 1g
- 2016-01-09 10y Newcastle United FC 0 at Watford FC 1 Troy Deeney ENG-WAXQ 90min 1g
- 2015-09-19 11y Watford FC 2 at Newcastle United FC 1 Odion Jude Ighalo ENG-WAXQ 90min 2g
- 2010-02-27 16y Newcastle United FC 2 at Watford FC 1 Fabricio Coloccini ENG-NEJP 90min 1g
- 2009-12-05 16y Watford FC 0 at Newcastle United FC 2 Peter Rosenkrands Løvenkrands ENG-NEJP 65min 1g
- 2007-05-13 19y Newcastle United FC 1 at Watford FC 1
- 2006-12-16 19y Watford FC 1 at Newcastle United FC 2 Obafemi Akinwunmi Martins ENG-NEJP 90min 2g
- 2006-11-07 19y Newcastle United FC 2 at Watford FC 2
- 2000-03-10 26y Watford FC 0 at Newcastle United FC 1
- 1999-11-19 26y Newcastle United FC 1 at Watford FC 1
- 1988-04-19 38y Newcastle United FC 1 at Watford FC 1
- 1988-04-12 38y Watford FC 0 at Newcastle United FC 3
- 1986-12-27 39y Newcastle United FC 0 at Watford FC 1
- 1986-11-15 39y Watford FC 2 at Newcastle United FC 2
- 1986-04-05 40y Newcastle United FC 1 at Watford FC 4
- 1985-11-02 40y Watford FC 1 at Newcastle United FC 1
- 1985-03-02 41y Watford FC 1 at Newcastle United FC 3
- 1984-10-27 42y Newcastle United FC 3 at Watford FC 3