- 2026-02-28 8mo Everton 3 at Newcastle United FC 2 Jarrad Branthwaite ENG-EVER 90min 1g
- 2025-11-29 11mo Newcastle United FC 4 at Everton 1 Malick Thiaw ENG-NEWC 90min 2g
- 2024-04-02 2y Everton 1 at Newcastle United FC 1
- 2023-12-07 2y Newcastle United FC 0 at Everton 3 Dwight McNeil ENG-EVER 90min
- 2023-04-27 3y Newcastle United FC 4 at Everton 1 Callum Wilson ENG-NEJP 90min
- 2022-10-19 4y Everton 0 at Newcastle United FC 1 Fabian Lukas Schär ENG-NEJP 90min yc
- 2022-03-17 4y Newcastle United FC 0 at Everton 1 Alex Iwobi ENG-EVFJ 90min 1g
- 2022-02-08 4y Everton 1 at Newcastle United FC 3 Jamaal Lascelles ENG-NEJP 90min 1g
- 2021-01-30 5y Newcastle United FC 2 at Everton 0 Callum Wilson ENG-NEJP 90min 2g
- 2020-11-01 6y Everton 1 at Newcastle United FC 2 Callum Wilson ENG-NEJP 87min 2g yc
- 2020-01-21 6y Newcastle United FC 2 at Everton 2
- 2019-12-28 6y Everton 2 at Newcastle United FC 1 Dominic Calvert-Lewin ENG-EVFJ 90min 2g yc
- 2019-03-09 7y Everton 2 at Newcastle United FC 3 Ayoze Pérez Gutiérrez ENG-NEJP 90min 2g
- 2018-12-05 7y Newcastle United FC 1 at Everton 1
- 2018-04-23 8y Newcastle United FC 0 at Everton 1 Theo Walcott ENG-EVFJ 90min 1g
- 2017-12-13 8y Everton 1 at Newcastle United FC 0 Wayne Mark Rooney ENG-EVFJ 77min 1g
- 2016-02-03 10y Newcastle United FC 0 at Everton 3 Ross Barkley ENG-EVFJ 90min 2g
- 2015-12-26 10y Everton 1 at Newcastle United FC 0 Tom Cleverley ENG-EVFJ 90min 1g
- 2015-03-15 11y Newcastle United FC 0 at Everton 3 Romelu Lukaku Menama ENG-EVFJ 74min 1g
- 2014-12-28 11y Everton 2 at Newcastle United FC 3 Jack Colback ENG-NEJP 90min 1g
- 2014-03-25 12y Everton 3 at Newcastle United FC 0 Romelu Lukaku Menama ENG-EVFJ 90min 1g
- 2013-09-30 13y Newcastle United FC 2 at Everton 3 Romelu Lukaku Menama ENG-EVFJ 90min 2g 1a
- 2013-01-02 13y Everton 2 at Newcastle United FC 1 Leighton Baines ENG-EVER 90min 1g
- 2012-09-17 14y Newcastle United FC 2 at Everton 2
- 2012-05-13 14y Newcastle United FC 1 at Everton 3 Tony Hibbert ENG-EVFJ 90min 1g
- 2011-11-05 15y Everton 1 at Newcastle United FC 2 Ryan Taylor ENG-NEJP 90min 1g yc
- 2011-03-05 15y Everton 2 at Newcastle United FC 1 Phil Jagielka ENG-EVFJ 90min 1g
- 2010-09-18 16y Newcastle United FC 1 at Everton 0 Hatem Ben Arfa ENG-NEJP 84min 1g
- 2009-02-22 17y Everton 0 at Newcastle United FC 0
- 2008-10-05 18y Newcastle United FC 2 at Everton 2
- 2008-05-11 18y Newcastle United FC 1 at Everton 3 Yakubu Aiyegbeni ENG-EVFJ 90min 2g
- 2007-10-07 19y Everton 2 at Newcastle United FC 3 Shay Given ENG-NEJP 90min 1g
- 2006-12-30 19y Newcastle United FC 0 at Everton 3 Phil Neville ENG-EVFJ 90min 1g
- 2006-09-24 20y Everton 1 at Newcastle United FC 1
- 2006-02-25 20y Everton 0 at Newcastle United FC 2 Nolberto Albino Solano Todco ENG-NEJP 90min 2g
- 2005-11-27 20y Newcastle United FC 0 at Everton 1 Joseph Phillip Yobo ENG-EVFJ 90min 1g
- 2005-05-07 21y Newcastle United FC 0 at Everton 2 David Weir ENG-EVER 90min 1g
- 2004-11-28 21y Everton 1 at Newcastle United FC 1
- 2004-04-03 22y Everton 2 at Newcastle United FC 4 Alan Shearer ENG-NEJP 90min 2g
- 2003-09-13 23y Newcastle United FC 2 at Everton 2
- 2003-04-05 23y Newcastle United FC 1 at Everton 2
- 2002-11-30 23y Everton 1 at Newcastle United FC 2
- 2002-03-28 24y Everton 2 at Newcastle United FC 6
- 2001-10-26 25y Newcastle United FC 3 at Everton 1
- 2001-03-02 25y Newcastle United FC 1 at Everton 1
- 2000-10-20 26y Everton 1 at Newcastle United FC 0
- 2000-03-18 26y Newcastle United FC 2 at Everton 0
- 1999-11-06 27y Everton 1 at Newcastle United FC 1
- 1999-04-16 27y Everton 3 at Newcastle United FC 1
- 1998-11-22 27y Newcastle United FC 0 at Everton 1