- 2027-02-05 in 2mo Aston Villa at Sunderland
- 2026-04-19 7mo Sunderland 3 at Aston Villa 4 Emiliano Martínez ENG-ASTO 90min
- 2025-09-21 1y Aston Villa 1 at Sunderland 1
- 2018-03-07 8y Aston Villa 3 at Sunderland 0 Lewis Grabban ENG-ASPV 76min 1g
- 2017-11-22 8y Sunderland 1 at Aston Villa 2 Albert Danquah Adomah ENG-ASPV 87min 1g
- 2016-01-02 10y Aston Villa 1 at Sunderland 3 Jermain Colin Defoe ENG-SULI 90min 2g
- 2015-08-29 11y Sunderland 2 at Aston Villa 2
- 2015-03-14 11y Aston Villa 4 at Sunderland 0 Gabriel Imuetinyan Agbonlahor ENG-ASPV 90min 2g
- 2014-12-28 11y Sunderland 0 at Aston Villa 0
- 2014-01-01 12y Aston Villa 1 at Sunderland 0 Gabriel Imuetinyan Agbonlahor ENG-ASPV 90min 1g yc
- 2013-11-30 12y Sunderland 0 at Aston Villa 0
- 2013-04-29 13y Sunderland 1 at Aston Villa 6 Christian Benteke Liolo ENG-ASPV 79min 3g
- 2012-11-03 14y Aston Villa 1 at Sunderland 0 Gabriel Imuetinyan Agbonlahor ENG-ASPV 90min 1g
- 2012-04-21 14y Sunderland 0 at Aston Villa 0
- 2011-10-29 15y Aston Villa 2 at Sunderland 2
- 2011-01-05 15y Sunderland 1 at Aston Villa 0 Phil Bardsley ENG-SULI 90min 1g
- 2010-10-23 16y Aston Villa 0 at Sunderland 1 Simon Luc Hildebert Mignolet ENG-SULI 90min
- 2010-03-24 16y Sunderland 1 at Aston Villa 1
- 2009-12-15 16y Aston Villa 2 at Sunderland 0 James Philip Milner ENG-ASPV 90min 1g yc
- 2009-10-28 17y Aston Villa 0 at Sunderland 0 Bradley Guzan ENG-ASPV 90min
- 2009-01-17 17y Aston Villa 2 at Sunderland 1 Gareth Barry ENG-ASPV 90min 1g
- 2008-09-27 18y Sunderland 1 at Aston Villa 2 Ashley Young ENG-ASPV 90min 1g
- 2008-03-22 18y Sunderland 1 at Aston Villa 0 Michael Chopra ENG-SULI 31min 1g
- 2007-12-15 18y Aston Villa 1 at Sunderland 1
- 2006-05-07 20y Sunderland 1 at Aston Villa 2 Gareth Barry ENG-ASPV 90min 1g
- 2005-11-19 21y Aston Villa 3 at Sunderland 1 Gareth Barry ENG-ASPV 90min 1g
- 2003-05-02 23y Sunderland 0 at Aston Villa 1 Marcus Allbäck ENG-ASPV 90min 1g
- 2002-09-27 24y Aston Villa 0 at Sunderland 1
- 2001-12-31 24y Aston Villa 1 at Sunderland 1
- 2001-09-15 25y Sunderland 0 at Aston Villa 0
- 2001-03-04 25y Aston Villa 1 at Sunderland 1
- 2000-10-21 26y Sunderland 0 at Aston Villa 0
- 2000-04-28 26y Sunderland 1 at Aston Villa 1
- 1999-10-17 27y Aston Villa 1 at Sunderland 2
- 1997-01-31 29y Sunderland 0 at Aston Villa 1
- 1996-10-25 30y Aston Villa 0 at Sunderland 1
- 1985-05-04 41y Aston Villa 4 at Sunderland 0
- 1984-12-01 41y Sunderland 0 at Aston Villa 1
- 1984-03-24 42y Aston Villa 1 at Sunderland 0
- 1983-08-29 43y Sunderland 0 at Aston Villa 1
- 1983-01-15 43y Aston Villa 0 at Sunderland 2
- 1982-08-28 44y Sunderland 3 at Aston Villa 1
- 1982-02-02 44y Sunderland 0 at Aston Villa 1
- 1981-03-07 45y Aston Villa 2 at Sunderland 1
- 1980-10-04 46y Sunderland 0 at Aston Villa 4
- 1966-12-27 59y Sunderland 1 at Aston Villa 2
- 1966-12-26 59y Aston Villa 1 at Sunderland 2
- 1964-09-14 62y Sunderland 1 at Aston Villa 2
- 1964-09-09 62y Aston Villa 2 at Sunderland 2
- 1958-01-11 68y Sunderland 2 at Aston Villa 5