- 2010-03-13 16y Newcastle United FC 2 at Middlesbrough 2
- 2009-12-20 16y Middlesbrough 0 at Newcastle United FC 2 Marlon Harewood ENG-NEJP 66min 1g
- 2009-05-11 17y Middlesbrough 1 at Newcastle United FC 3 Habib Beye ENG-NEJP 90min 1g
- 2008-11-29 17y Newcastle United FC 0 at Middlesbrough 0
- 2008-02-03 18y Middlesbrough 1 at Newcastle United FC 1
- 2007-08-26 19y Newcastle United FC 2 at Middlesbrough 2
- 2007-03-03 19y Middlesbrough 0 at Newcastle United FC 0
- 2006-10-22 19y Newcastle United FC 0 at Middlesbrough 1 Yakubu Aiyegbeni ENG-MIRM 90min 1g
- 2006-04-09 20y Newcastle United FC 2 at Middlesbrough 1 Shola Ameobi ENG-NEJP 90min 1g yc
- 2006-01-02 20y Middlesbrough 2 at Newcastle United FC 2
- 2005-04-27 21y Middlesbrough 0 at Newcastle United FC 0
- 2004-02-21 22y Middlesbrough 1 at Newcastle United FC 2 Craig Bellamy ENG-NEJP 90min 1g
- 2003-10-18 23y Newcastle United FC 1 at Middlesbrough 0 Shola Ameobi ENG-NEJP 90min 1g
- 2003-03-04 23y Newcastle United FC 0 at Middlesbrough 1
- 2002-11-03 23y Middlesbrough 0 at Newcastle United FC 2
- 2001-12-25 24y Middlesbrough 0 at Newcastle United FC 3
- 2001-09-07 25y Newcastle United FC 4 at Middlesbrough 1
- 2001-03-16 25y Middlesbrough 2 at Newcastle United FC 1
- 2000-10-15 26y Newcastle United FC 3 at Middlesbrough 1
- 2000-05-01 26y Newcastle United FC 2 at Middlesbrough 2
- 1999-10-02 27y Middlesbrough 1 at Newcastle United FC 2
- 1999-04-30 27y Middlesbrough 1 at Newcastle United FC 1
- 1998-12-05 27y Newcastle United FC 2 at Middlesbrough 2
- 1997-02-21 29y Newcastle United FC 1 at Middlesbrough 0
- 1996-11-02 29y Middlesbrough 1 at Newcastle United FC 3
- 1996-02-09 30y Newcastle United FC 2 at Middlesbrough 1
- 1989-02-26 37y Newcastle United FC 1 at Middlesbrough 1
- 1988-10-26 37y Middlesbrough 0 at Newcastle United FC 3
- 1978-01-14 48y Middlesbrough 4 at Newcastle United FC 2
- 1976-01-31 50y Newcastle United FC 3 at Middlesbrough 3
- 1975-08-20 51y Middlesbrough 1 at Newcastle United FC 1
- 1975-02-01 51y Middlesbrough 1 at Newcastle United FC 2
- 1974-11-09 51y Newcastle United FC 0 at Middlesbrough 0
- 1953-12-26 72y Middlesbrough 3 at Newcastle United FC 2
- 1953-12-25 72y Newcastle United FC 3 at Middlesbrough 2
- 1953-04-06 73y Newcastle United FC 1 at Middlesbrough 2
- 1953-04-03 73y Middlesbrough 0 at Newcastle United FC 1
- 1952-04-14 74y Newcastle United FC 1 at Middlesbrough 2
- 1952-04-11 74y Middlesbrough 2 at Newcastle United FC 0
- 1951-05-05 75y Middlesbrough 0 at Newcastle United FC 1
- 1950-12-25 75y Newcastle United FC 1 at Middlesbrough 2
- 1949-12-27 76y Newcastle United FC 0 at Middlesbrough 1
- 1949-12-26 76y Middlesbrough 1 at Newcastle United FC 0
- 1949-04-18 77y Newcastle United FC 2 at Middlesbrough 3
- 1949-04-15 77y Middlesbrough 0 at Newcastle United FC 1
- 1934-04-02 92y Newcastle United FC 0 at Middlesbrough 1
- 1934-03-30 92y Middlesbrough 1 at Newcastle United FC 1
- 1933-01-02 93y Newcastle United FC 3 at Middlesbrough 2
- 1932-08-31 94y Middlesbrough 1 at Newcastle United FC 5
- 1932-02-20 94y Newcastle United FC 1 at Middlesbrough 2