- 2026-04-15 7mo Montego Bay United 0 at Arnett Gardens 1 Earl Simpson JAM-ARNE 90min
- 2026-03-01 8mo Arnett Gardens 1 at Montego Bay United 1
- 2025-12-15 11mo Montego Bay United 1 at Arnett Gardens 0 Jaheim Williams JAM-MONT 90min
- 2025-05-23 1y Montego Bay United 2 at Arnett Gardens 4 Fabian Reid JAM-ARNE 90min 2g
- 2024-02-11 2y Arnett Gardens 0 at Montego Bay United 0
- 2023-11-19 3y Arnett Gardens 3 at Montego Bay United 1
- 2023-03-12 3y Montego Bay United 1 at Arnett Gardens 1
- 2022-11-21 3y Arnett Gardens 1 at Montego Bay United 2 Kevin Graham JAM-MOZA 49min yc
- 2022-05-08 4y Arnett Gardens 2 at Montego Bay United 2
- 2022-02-19 4y Montego Bay United 1 at Arnett Gardens 3 Gerald Neil JAM-ARGD 90min yc
- 2019-03-11 7y Arnett Gardens 2 at Montego Bay United 1 Zhelano Barnes JAM-ARGD 74min 1g
- 2018-11-26 7y Montego Bay United 0 at Arnett Gardens 3 Fabian Reid JAM-ARGD 90min 3g
- 2018-11-06 8y Montego Bay United 0 at Arnett Gardens 0
- 2018-03-05 8y Arnett Gardens 1 at Montego Bay United 1
- 2017-12-15 8y Montego Bay United 0 at Arnett Gardens 3 Fabian Reid JAM-ARGD 70min 2g
- 2017-11-07 9y Montego Bay United 0 at Arnett Gardens 1 Keneil Hyde JAM-ARGD 90min 1g
- 2017-03-10 9y Montego Bay United 2 at Arnett Gardens 1 Donovan Carey JAM-MOZA 90min 1g
- 2016-11-25 9y Arnett Gardens 0 at Montego Bay United 2 Dino Williams JAM-MOZA 90min 1g
- 2016-11-21 9y Arnett Gardens 0 at Montego Bay United 2 Donovan Carey JAM-MOZA 73min 1g
- 2016-03-28 10y Montego Bay United 1 at Arnett Gardens 2
- 2016-01-11 10y Montego Bay United 1 at Arnett Gardens 2
- 2015-11-03 11y Arnett Gardens 2 at Montego Bay United 2
- 2015-06-02 11y Arnett Gardens 2 at Montego Bay United 0
- 2015-03-02 11y Montego Bay United 1 at Arnett Gardens 1
- 2015-01-27 11y Montego Bay United 0 at Arnett Gardens 0
- 2014-11-27 11y Arnett Gardens 0 at Montego Bay United 5
- 2014-04-21 12y Arnett Gardens 1 at Montego Bay United 0
- 2014-02-11 12y Montego Bay United 0 at Arnett Gardens 1
- 2013-11-04 13y Montego Bay United 2 at Arnett Gardens 1
- 2013-04-01 13y Arnett Gardens 0 at Montego Bay United 4
- 2013-01-14 13y Montego Bay United 0 at Arnett Gardens 1
- 2012-10-29 14y Arnett Gardens 0 at Montego Bay United 1
- 2012-04-30 14y Arnett Gardens 1 at Montego Bay United 1
- 2012-04-02 14y Montego Bay United 2 at Arnett Gardens 1
- 2012-01-19 14y Arnett Gardens 0 at Montego Bay United 1
- 2011-11-14 15y Montego Bay United 2 at Arnett Gardens 1
- 2008-05-11 18y Arnett Gardens 2 at Montego Bay United 1