- 2013-01-26 13y Everton 2 at Bolton Wanderers 1 Steven Pienaar ENG-EVER 90min 1g
- 2012-01-04 14y Bolton Wanderers 2 at Everton 1 Gary Cahill ENG-BOZJ 90min 1g yc
- 2011-11-26 14y Everton 2 at Bolton Wanderers 0 Marouane Fellaini-Bakkioui ENG-EVFJ 90min 1g
- 2011-02-13 15y Everton 0 at Bolton Wanderers 2 Gary Cahill ENG-BOZJ 90min 1g
- 2010-11-10 16y Bolton Wanderers 1 at Everton 1
- 2010-03-20 16y Bolton Wanderers 0 at Everton 2 Steven Pienaar ENG-EVER 90min 1g
- 2009-10-25 17y Everton 2 at Bolton Wanderers 3 Chung-Yong Lee ENG-BOZJ 88min 1g
- 2009-02-07 17y Bolton Wanderers 0 at Everton 3 João Alves de Assis Silva ENG-EVFJ 90min 2g
- 2008-10-29 18y Everton 1 at Bolton Wanderers 0 Marouane Fellaini-Bakkioui ENG-EVFJ 90min 1g yc
- 2007-12-26 18y Bolton Wanderers 0 at Everton 2 Tim Cahill ENG-EVFJ 90min 1g
- 2007-09-01 19y Everton 2 at Bolton Wanderers 1 Yakubu Aiyegbeni ENG-EVFJ 84min 1g
- 2007-04-09 19y Everton 1 at Bolton Wanderers 1
- 2006-11-18 20y Bolton Wanderers 0 at Everton 1 Mikel Arteta Amatriain ENG-EVFJ 90min 1g
- 2005-12-17 20y Bolton Wanderers 4 at Everton 0 Stylianos Giannakopoulos ENG-BOZJ 90min 2g
- 2005-08-21 21y Everton 1 at Bolton Wanderers 0 Marcus Bent ENG-EVFJ 60min 1g
- 2005-05-15 21y Everton 2 at Bolton Wanderers 3 Radhi Ben Abdelmajid Jaïdi ENG-BOLT 90min 1g
- 2004-12-04 21y Bolton Wanderers 2 at Everton 3 Thomas Gravesen ENG-EVER 90min 1g
- 2004-05-08 22y Bolton Wanderers 2 at Everton 1 Youri Djorkaeff ENG-BOZJ 90min 2g
- 2003-11-29 22y Everton 0 at Bolton Wanderers 2 Kevin Nolan ENG-BOZJ 90min 1g
- 2003-01-27 23y Everton 2 at Bolton Wanderers 1
- 2002-12-27 23y Bolton Wanderers 0 at Everton 0
- 2002-03-31 24y Bolton Wanderers 1 at Everton 3
- 2001-11-02 25y Everton 2 at Bolton Wanderers 2
- 1997-12-27 28y Bolton Wanderers 2 at Everton 3
- 1997-08-31 29y Everton 0 at Bolton Wanderers 0
- 1996-04-05 30y Bolton Wanderers 0 at Everton 3
- 1980-04-05 46y Bolton Wanderers 1 at Everton 3
- 1979-12-26 46y Everton 1 at Bolton Wanderers 1
- 1979-04-16 47y Bolton Wanderers 0 at Everton 1
- 1979-04-03 47y Everton 1 at Bolton Wanderers 3
- 1963-09-11 63y Bolton Wanderers 0 at Everton 2
- 1963-09-04 63y Everton 3 at Bolton Wanderers 1
- 1963-05-04 63y Bolton Wanderers 0 at Everton 1
- 1962-09-15 64y Everton 2 at Bolton Wanderers 0
- 1962-04-04 64y Everton 1 at Bolton Wanderers 1
- 1961-12-26 64y Bolton Wanderers 0 at Everton 1
- 1961-02-04 65y Bolton Wanderers 2 at Everton 1
- 1960-09-17 66y Everton 4 at Bolton Wanderers 3
- 1960-01-02 66y Bolton Wanderers 1 at Everton 0
- 1959-08-29 67y Everton 1 at Bolton Wanderers 2
- 1958-12-27 67y Everton 3 at Bolton Wanderers 0
- 1958-12-26 67y Bolton Wanderers 0 at Everton 1
- 1957-12-26 68y Everton 5 at Bolton Wanderers 1
- 1957-12-25 68y Bolton Wanderers 1 at Everton 1
- 1957-04-27 69y Everton 1 at Bolton Wanderers 1
- 1956-02-25 70y Bolton Wanderers 0 at Everton 1
- 1955-10-15 71y Everton 1 at Bolton Wanderers 1
- 1955-04-16 71y Everton 0 at Bolton Wanderers 2
- 1951-03-03 75y Everton 0 at Bolton Wanderers 2
- 1950-10-14 76y Bolton Wanderers 1 at Everton 1