- 2024-06-22 2y Saint Peters 3 at Newtown United 2
- 2024-03-27 2y Newtown United 3 at Saint Peters 1
- 2023-06-10 3y Saint Peters 0 at Newtown United 1
- 2023-03-19 3y Newtown United 3 at Saint Peters 3
- 2021-04-17 5y Newtown United 0 at Saint Peters 1
- 2020-11-07 5y Newtown United 1 at Saint Peters 4
- 2020-02-17 6y Saint Peters 6 at Newtown United 0
- 2019-05-19 7y Newtown United 4 at Saint Peters 1
- 2019-01-21 7y Saint Peters 1 at Newtown United 1
- 2018-10-21 8y Saint Peters 1 at Newtown United 3
- 2018-05-20 8y Saint Peters 3 at Newtown United 0
- 2018-02-05 8y Newtown United 0 at Saint Peters 2
- 2017-12-11 8y Saint Peters 3 at Newtown United 2
- 2017-03-29 9y Saint Peters 0 at Newtown United 3
- 2016-12-12 9y Newtown United 2 at Saint Peters 2
- 2016-10-31 9y Saint Peters 0 at Newtown United 1
- 2010-05-20 16y Newtown United 3 at Saint Peters 0
- 2008-03-10 18y Newtown United 5 at Saint Peters 0
- 2007-11-11 18y Newtown United 3 at Saint Peters 0
- 2007-04-28 19y Saint Peters 0 at Newtown United 3