- 2026-03-14 8mo Cheltenham Town 2 at Shrewsbury Town 0 Sam Sherring ENG-CHET 90min 1g
- 2025-12-26 10mo Shrewsbury Town 1 at Cheltenham Town 3 Jake Bickerstaff ENG-CHET 86min 1g
- 2023-12-26 2y Shrewsbury Town 0 at Cheltenham Town 2 George Robert Lawrence Lloyd ENG-CHET 90min 2g
- 2023-08-05 3y Cheltenham Town 0 at Shrewsbury Town 1 Ryan Michael Bowman ENG-SHRE 90min 1g yc
- 2022-12-29 3y Cheltenham Town 1 at Shrewsbury Town 0 Dan Nlundulu Konda ENG-CHUX 81min 1g yc
- 2022-09-30 4y Shrewsbury Town 0 at Cheltenham Town 2 Sean Martin Long ENG-CHUX 90min 1g
- 2021-12-18 4y Cheltenham Town 1 at Shrewsbury Town 3 Dominic Daniel Udoh ENG-SHSB 80min 2g
- 2021-11-20 4y Shrewsbury Town 1 at Cheltenham Town 2 Scott Liam Flinders ENG-CHUX 90min
- 2015-04-25 11y Shrewsbury Town 1 at Cheltenham Town 0 Jean-Louis Akpa Akpro ENG-SHSB 71min 1g
- 2014-10-11 12y Cheltenham Town 1 at Shrewsbury Town 3 Nathaniel Lawrence Knight-Percival ENG-SHSB 90min 1g
- 2012-03-21 14y Cheltenham Town 0 at Shrewsbury Town 2 Nicky Wroe ENG-SHSB 90min 1g
- 2011-12-26 14y Shrewsbury Town 0 at Cheltenham Town 0
- 2011-04-30 15y Shrewsbury Town 1 at Cheltenham Town 0 Mark Wright ENG-SHSB 90min 1g
- 2010-12-11 15y Cheltenham Town 1 at Shrewsbury Town 1
- 2010-04-14 16y Cheltenham Town 0 at Shrewsbury Town 0
- 2009-09-30 17y Shrewsbury Town 2 at Cheltenham Town 1 Joss Christopher Labadie ENG-SHSB 90min 1g
- 2006-04-01 20y Cheltenham Town 0 at Shrewsbury Town 2
- 2005-12-31 20y Shrewsbury Town 0 at Cheltenham Town 1
- 2005-10-18 21y Cheltenham Town 2 at Shrewsbury Town 0
- 2005-04-08 21y Shrewsbury Town 1 at Cheltenham Town 1
- 2004-08-31 22y Cheltenham Town 0 at Shrewsbury Town 2
- 2001-12-26 24y Shrewsbury Town 0 at Cheltenham Town 1
- 2001-01-20 25y Cheltenham Town 0 at Shrewsbury Town 1
- 2000-12-26 25y Shrewsbury Town 1 at Cheltenham Town 1