- 2016-03-02 10y York City 0 at Oxford Utd 4 Cheyenne Dunkley ENG-OXFO 90min 1g
- 2015-09-30 11y Oxford Utd 2 at York City 1 Danny Hylton ENG-OXFO 90min 1g
- 2015-04-06 11y York City 0 at Oxford Utd 0
- 2014-11-15 11y Oxford Utd 1 at York City 0 James Anthony Roberts ENG-OXFO 90min 1g
- 2014-04-18 12y York City 1 at Oxford Utd 0 Michael Coulson ENG-YOSM 90min 1g yc
- 2013-12-21 12y Oxford Utd 0 at York City 0
- 2013-02-23 13y York City 0 at Oxford Utd 0
- 2010-05-16 16y York City 1 at Oxford Utd 3 Ryan James Clarke ENG-OXFO 90min 1g
- 2009-10-17 17y Oxford Utd 1 at York City 1
- 2009-04-08 17y Oxford Utd 0 at York City 0
- 2009-01-14 17y York City 2 at Oxford Utd 1
- 2008-11-01 17y York City 0 at Oxford Utd 1
- 2008-04-16 18y Oxford Utd 1 at York City 0
- 2007-09-30 19y York City 1 at Oxford Utd 1
- 2007-04-28 19y Oxford Utd 0 at York City 1
- 2006-09-30 20y York City 0 at Oxford Utd 2
- 2004-03-03 22y York City 0 at Oxford Utd 0
- 2003-10-21 23y Oxford Utd 2 at York City 2
- 2003-05-03 23y York City 0 at Oxford Utd 2
- 2002-04-01 24y Oxford Utd 0 at York City 1
- 1996-02-20 30y Oxford Utd 0 at York City 1
- 1995-04-22 31y Oxford Utd 2 at York City 0
- 1995-01-02 31y York City 2 at Oxford Utd 0