- 2017-02-18 9y Plymouth Argyle 1 at Hartlepool United FC 1
- 2016-09-24 10y Hartlepool United FC 1 at Plymouth Argyle 1
- 2016-05-07 10y Hartlepool United FC 0 at Plymouth Argyle 5 Tyler Harvey ENG-PLGG 90min 2g
- 2015-12-19 10y Plymouth Argyle 2 at Hartlepool United FC 1 Carl Gerard McHugh ENG-PLGG 90min 1g
- 2015-01-31 11y Plymouth Argyle 2 at Hartlepool United FC 3 Jonathan Franks ENG-HAWM 90min 2g
- 2014-09-20 12y Hartlepool United FC 0 at Plymouth Argyle 2 Marvin Morgan ENG-PLGG 87min 1g
- 2014-04-26 12y Hartlepool United FC 1 at Plymouth Argyle 1
- 2013-10-19 13y Plymouth Argyle 0 at Hartlepool United FC 1 Luke Myers James ENG-HAWM 90min 1g
- 2011-03-12 15y Plymouth Argyle 0 at Hartlepool United FC 2 Sam Collins ENG-HAWM 90min 1g
- 2010-10-02 16y Hartlepool United FC 1 at Plymouth Argyle 0 Leon McSweeney ENG-HAWM 89min 1g
- 2003-11-22 22y Hartlepool United FC 0 at Plymouth Argyle 2
- 2002-04-01 24y Plymouth Argyle 0 at Hartlepool United FC 1
- 2001-03-24 25y Hartlepool United FC 2 at Plymouth Argyle 0
- 1999-03-13 27y Hartlepool United FC 0 at Plymouth Argyle 0
- 1996-05-04 30y Hartlepool United FC 0 at Plymouth Argyle 3
- 1995-11-18 30y Plymouth Argyle 2 at Hartlepool United FC 2
- 1993-11-27 32y Hartlepool United FC 0 at Plymouth Argyle 2