- 2024-08-03 2y Mansfield Town 1 at Grimsby Town 0
- 2023-12-26 2y Grimsby Town 0 at Mansfield Town 2 Davis James Marshall Keillor-Dunn ENG-MANS 85min 1g
- 2023-08-19 3y Mansfield Town 1 at Grimsby Town 1
- 2023-08-08 3y Grimsby Town 0 at Mansfield Town 2 Lucas-Jordan Jeremiah Akins ENG-MANS 90min 1g
- 2023-04-15 3y Mansfield Town 1 at Grimsby Town 1
- 2023-03-22 3y Grimsby Town 0 at Mansfield Town 0
- 2022-09-20 4y Mansfield Town 0 at Grimsby Town 2 Shaun Mark Pearson ENG-GRIM 90min yc
- 2021-07-20 5y Grimsby Town 1 at Mansfield Town 0
- 2021-03-20 5y Grimsby Town 2 at Mansfield Town 2
- 2020-12-12 5y Mansfield Town 1 at Grimsby Town 1
- 2020-01-04 6y Grimsby Town 1 at Mansfield Town 0 James Karl McKeown ENG-GRIM 90min yc
- 2019-10-05 7y Mansfield Town 1 at Grimsby Town 0 Krystian Mitchell Victor Pearce ENG-MANS 90min 1g
- 2019-01-01 7y Mansfield Town 1 at Grimsby Town 0 Neal Bishop ENG-MANS 90min 1g
- 2018-11-07 7y Grimsby Town 1 at Mansfield Town 2 Tyler Walker ENG-MANS 90min 2g
- 2017-12-26 8y Mansfield Town 1 at Grimsby Town 1
- 2017-02-18 9y Mansfield Town 0 at Grimsby Town 3 Calum Dyson ENG-GRIM 90min 2g
- 2016-09-24 10y Grimsby Town 1 at Mansfield Town 0 Omar Hanif Bogle ENG-GRIM 90min 1g
- 2013-03-13 13y Grimsby Town 0 at Mansfield Town 2 Adam Chapman ENG-MANS 90min 1g yc
- 2012-08-27 14y Mansfield Town 1 at Grimsby Town 4 Greg Pearson ENG-GRIM 90min 2g
- 2011-12-07 14y Mansfield Town 0 at Grimsby Town 0
- 2011-10-08 15y Grimsby Town 1 at Mansfield Town 2 Paul Connor ENG-MANS 35min 1g
- 2011-04-20 15y Grimsby Town 2 at Mansfield Town 0 Michael Coulson ENG-GRIM 89min 1g
- 2011-01-01 15y Mansfield Town 2 at Grimsby Town 7 Peter Bore ENG-GRIM 90min 3g
- 2008-03-22 18y Grimsby Town 2 at Mansfield Town 1
- 2007-12-15 18y Mansfield Town 0 at Grimsby Town 1
- 2006-02-14 20y Grimsby Town 1 at Mansfield Town 2
- 2006-01-14 20y Mansfield Town 1 at Grimsby Town 2
- 2005-04-02 21y Grimsby Town 0 at Mansfield Town 2
- 2004-08-28 22y Mansfield Town 0 at Grimsby Town 2