- 2024-03-29 2y Carlisle United FC 3 at Peterborough United 1 Jon James Alexander Mellish ENG-CAQF 90min 3g yc
- 2023-10-03 3y Peterborough United 1 at Carlisle United FC 1
- 2014-11-08 12y Carlisle United FC 1 at Peterborough United 2 Christian Albert Elliot Burgess ENG-PEWX 90min 2g
- 2014-04-21 12y Carlisle United FC 1 at Peterborough United 4 Britt Curtis Assombalonga ENG-PEWX 90min 2g
- 2013-12-29 12y Peterborough United 1 at Carlisle United FC 2 David Oluwaseun Segun Amoo ENG-CAQF 90min 2g
- 2011-03-12 15y Carlisle United FC 0 at Peterborough United 6 George Boyd ENG-PEWX 90min 2g
- 2010-10-02 16y Peterborough United 1 at Carlisle United FC 0 Craig Mackail-Smith ENG-PEWX 90min 1g
- 2009-02-25 17y Carlisle United FC 0 at Peterborough United 1 Aaron McLean ENG-PEWX 90min 1g
- 2008-10-18 18y Peterborough United 3 at Carlisle United FC 3
- 2005-12-10 20y Carlisle United FC 1 at Peterborough United 1
- 1999-04-10 27y Peterborough United 1 at Carlisle United FC 1
- 1996-02-17 30y Carlisle United FC 1 at Peterborough United 6