- 2026-05-02 6mo Shrewsbury Town 0 at Gillingham 1 Jake Turner ENG-GILN 0min
- 2025-11-29 11mo Gillingham 3 at Shrewsbury Town 3
- 2022-01-25 4y Shrewsbury Town 0 at Gillingham 0
- 2021-08-28 5y Gillingham 1 at Shrewsbury Town 2 Tom Bloxham ENG-SHSB 65min 1g
- 2021-04-10 5y Shrewsbury Town 0 at Gillingham 0
- 2020-10-03 6y Gillingham 1 at Shrewsbury Town 1
- 2020-01-29 6y Shrewsbury Town 0 at Gillingham 2 Oliver Robert Lee ENG-GIJT 90min 1g
- 2019-10-22 7y Gillingham 1 at Shrewsbury Town 1
- 2019-04-13 7y Shrewsbury Town 2 at Gillingham 0 James William Bolton ENG-SHSB 80min 1g
- 2018-09-29 8y Gillingham 2 at Shrewsbury Town 2
- 2018-02-21 8y Gillingham 1 at Shrewsbury Town 1
- 2017-01-28 9y Shrewsbury Town 1 at Gillingham 1
- 2016-04-23 10y Shrewsbury Town 3 at Gillingham 2 Sullay Borbor Kaikai ENG-SHSB 90min 1g
- 2015-11-28 10y Gillingham 2 at Shrewsbury Town 2
- 2014-05-03 12y Shrewsbury Town 1 at Gillingham 1
- 2013-10-12 13y Gillingham 0 at Shrewsbury Town 2 Joseph Mark Jacobson ENG-SHSB 90min 1g
- 2012-01-14 14y Gillingham 0 at Shrewsbury Town 2 Shane Cansdell-Sherriff ENG-SHSB 90min 1g
- 2011-02-26 15y Gillingham 0 at Shrewsbury Town 0
- 2009-05-23 17y Shrewsbury Town 0 at Gillingham 1 Simeon Alexander Jackson ENG-GIJT 90min 1g
- 2009-03-14 17y Shrewsbury Town 2 at Gillingham 2
- 2008-09-13 18y Gillingham 0 at Shrewsbury Town 7 Ben Davies ENG-SHSB 90min 2g
- 1997-05-03 29y Shrewsbury Town 0 at Gillingham 2
- 1996-10-15 30y Gillingham 2 at Shrewsbury Town 1
- 1994-03-12 32y Shrewsbury Town 2 at Gillingham 0