- 2024-08-17 2y Peterborough United 4 at Shrewsbury Town 1 Joel John Randall ENG-PETE 90min 2g
- 2024-01-20 2y Shrewsbury Town 1 at Peterborough United 2 Josh Knight ENG-PETE 90min 1g
- 2023-12-23 2y Peterborough United 2 at Shrewsbury Town 1 Hector Matthew Kyprianou ENG-PETE 90min 1g 1a
- 2023-04-07 3y Peterborough United 3 at Shrewsbury Town 0 Jonson Clarke-Harris ENG-PEWX 90min 1g
- 2023-03-07 3y Shrewsbury Town 1 at Peterborough United 2 Frankie Kent ENG-PEWX 90min 1g
- 2022-11-26 3y Peterborough United 1 at Shrewsbury Town 3 Matthew Pennington ENG-SHSB 90min 1g
- 2021-01-30 5y Peterborough United 0 at Shrewsbury Town 2 Harrison James Chapman ENG-SHSB 88min 2g
- 2020-10-31 6y Shrewsbury Town 1 at Peterborough United 5 Siriki Dembélé ENG-PEWX 90min 3g
- 2019-11-05 7y Peterborough United 0 at Shrewsbury Town 1 Ethan Reid Ebanks-Landell ENG-SHSB 90min 1g
- 2019-02-23 7y Shrewsbury Town 2 at Peterborough United 1 Tyrese Campbell ENG-SHSB 63min 1g
- 2018-12-15 7y Peterborough United 2 at Shrewsbury Town 2
- 2018-04-25 8y Peterborough United 1 at Shrewsbury Town 3 Omar Jerome Beckles ENG-SHSB 90min 1g
- 2017-10-28 9y Shrewsbury Town 0 at Peterborough United 1 Marcus Maddison ENG-PEWX 80min 1g yc
- 2017-02-15 9y Shrewsbury Town 1 at Peterborough United 2 Ryan Sirous Tafazolli ENG-PEWX 90min 1g
- 2016-09-28 10y Peterborough United 1 at Shrewsbury Town 1
- 2016-04-30 10y Peterborough United 4 at Shrewsbury Town 3 Lee Anthony Angol ENG-PEWX 90min 2g
- 2015-12-12 10y Shrewsbury Town 1 at Peterborough United 1
- 2014-04-26 12y Peterborough United 4 at Shrewsbury Town 2 Conor James Washington ENG-PEWX 75min 2g
- 2013-10-19 13y Shrewsbury Town 0 at Peterborough United 1 Nathaniel Mendez-Laing ENG-PEWX 28min 1g
- 2008-01-01 18y Shrewsbury Town 1 at Peterborough United 2
- 2007-10-03 19y Peterborough United 2 at Shrewsbury Town 0
- 2006-02-11 20y Peterborough United 1 at Shrewsbury Town 2
- 1999-02-20 27y Shrewsbury Town 2 at Peterborough United 2
- 1998-03-14 28y Peterborough United 1 at Shrewsbury Town 4
- 1997-11-04 29y Shrewsbury Town 1 at Peterborough United 1
- 1997-01-25 29y Peterborough United 2 at Shrewsbury Town 2
- 1996-10-29 30y Shrewsbury Town 2 at Peterborough United 2
- 1996-03-19 30y Peterborough United 1 at Shrewsbury Town 1
- 1996-02-10 30y Shrewsbury Town 2 at Peterborough United 2
- 1995-03-07 31y Shrewsbury Town 1 at Peterborough United 1