- 2026-04-06 6mo Plymouth Argyle 3 at Barnsley 0 Owen Oseni ENG-PLYM 81min 2g
- 2025-08-02 1y Barnsley 3 at Plymouth Argyle 1 Davis James Marshall Keillor-Dunn ENG-BARS 90min 1g
- 2023-03-11 3y Plymouth Argyle 0 at Barnsley 3 Mads Juel Andersen ENG-BAXL 90min 1g
- 2022-07-30 4y Barnsley 0 at Plymouth Argyle 1 Finn Isaac Azaz ENG-PLGG 78min 1g
- 2019-04-22 7y Barnsley 3 at Plymouth Argyle 0 Alex Mowatt ENG-BAXL 90min 1g
- 2018-10-03 8y Plymouth Argyle 1 at Barnsley 1
- 2010-03-31 16y Barnsley 0 at Plymouth Argyle 0
- 2010-02-13 16y Plymouth Argyle 3 at Barnsley 1 Carl Fletcher ENG-PLGG 90min 1g
- 2009-05-03 17y Barnsley 2 at Plymouth Argyle 1 Jamal Julian Campbell-Ryce ENG-BAXL 90min 1g
- 2008-12-20 17y Plymouth Argyle 0 at Barnsley 2 Anderson Silva de França ENG-BAXL 90min 1g
- 2008-02-13 18y Barnsley 0 at Plymouth Argyle 3
- 2007-08-25 19y Plymouth Argyle 2 at Barnsley 3
- 2007-03-15 19y Barnsley 4 at Plymouth Argyle 2
- 2004-04-03 22y Plymouth Argyle 0 at Barnsley 1
- 2003-09-27 23y Barnsley 0 at Plymouth Argyle 2
- 2003-03-01 23y Barnsley 1 at Plymouth Argyle 1