- 2025-03-04 1y Barnsley 0 at Charlton 1 Macaulay Gillesphey ENG-CHAA 90min
- 2024-10-22 1y Charlton 2 at Barnsley 2
- 2024-04-06 2y Barnsley 1 at Charlton 2 Alfie Ben May ENG-CHAA 88min 2g
- 2023-12-16 2y Charlton 1 at Barnsley 1
- 2023-01-14 3y Barnsley 0 at Charlton 2 Tyreece Campbell ENG-CHRW 83min 1g
- 2022-09-24 4y Charlton 1 at Barnsley 3 James Hammond Norwood ENG-BAXL 60min 1g
- 2020-02-01 6y Barnsley 1 at Charlton 2 Lyle James Alfred Taylor ENG-CHRW 68min 1g
- 2018-12-29 7y Charlton 1 at Barnsley 2 Brad Potts ENG-BAXL 77min 1g
- 2018-10-20 8y Barnsley 0 at Charlton 2 Karlan Ahearne-Grant ENG-CHRW 90min 2g
- 2014-04-16 12y Barnsley 2 at Charlton 1 Tom Kennedy ENG-BAXL 90min 1g
- 2013-04-13 13y Charlton 6 at Barnsley 0 Bradley Pritchard ENG-CHRW 90min 1g
- 2012-10-20 14y Barnsley 1 at Charlton 0 Tomasz Cywka ENG-BAXL 90min 1g
- 2009-02-21 17y Charlton 0 at Barnsley 0
- 2008-11-01 17y Barnsley 3 at Charlton 1 Jon Macken ENG-BAXL 90min 2g
- 2008-04-26 18y Charlton 0 at Barnsley 3
- 2007-10-06 19y Barnsley 1 at Charlton 1
- 1997-04-12 29y Charlton 0 at Barnsley 4
- 1997-02-15 29y Barnsley 2 at Charlton 2
- 1995-12-16 30y Charlton 2 at Barnsley 1
- 1995-09-30 31y Barnsley 1 at Charlton 1
- 1994-12-10 31y Charlton 1 at Barnsley 2
- 1994-08-20 32y Barnsley 2 at Charlton 2
- 1994-01-22 32y Barnsley 1 at Charlton 2
- 1993-10-09 33y Charlton 1 at Barnsley 0