- 2024-03-29 2y Oxford Utd 1 at Shrewsbury Town 1
- 2023-10-03 3y Shrewsbury Town 0 at Oxford Utd 3 Ciaron Maurice Brown ENG-OXFO 90min 1g
- 2023-02-04 3y Shrewsbury Town 1 at Oxford Utd 0 Ryan Michael Bowman ENG-SHSB 37min 1g
- 2022-11-09 3y Oxford Utd 1 at Shrewsbury Town 1
- 2022-03-12 4y Oxford Utd 2 at Shrewsbury Town 1 Cameron Mark Thomas Brannagan ENG-OXFO 90min 1g
- 2021-10-19 5y Shrewsbury Town 0 at Oxford Utd 2 Cameron Mark Thomas Brannagan ENG-OXFO 90min 1g
- 2021-05-01 5y Oxford Utd 3 at Shrewsbury Town 2 James Henry ENG-OXFO 89min 1g
- 2021-04-13 5y Shrewsbury Town 1 at Oxford Utd 4 Samuel Patrick Robert Long ENG-OXFO 86min 1g
- 2020-03-07 6y Oxford Utd 3 at Shrewsbury Town 2 Josh Ruffels ENG-OXFO 90min 1g
- 2019-12-07 6y Shrewsbury Town 0 at Oxford Utd 0
- 2019-04-22 7y Oxford Utd 3 at Shrewsbury Town 2 Gavin Whyte ENG-OXFO 90min 3g yc
- 2018-10-27 7y Shrewsbury Town 0 at Oxford Utd 3 Josh Ruffels ENG-OXFO 90min 1g
- 2018-04-02 8y Oxford Utd 2 at Shrewsbury Town 3 Shaun James Whalley ENG-SHSB 86min 2g
- 2017-04-30 9y Shrewsbury Town 0 at Oxford Utd 2 Curtis Nelson ENG-OXFO 90min 1g
- 2016-11-12 9y Oxford Utd 0 at Shrewsbury Town 2 Ajay Leitch-Smith ENG-SHSB 76min 1g
- 2015-03-21 11y Oxford Utd 0 at Shrewsbury Town 2 Liam Lawrence ENG-SHSB 90min 2g
- 2014-12-26 11y Shrewsbury Town 2 at Oxford Utd 0 Mark Ian Ellis ENG-SHSB 90min 1g
- 2012-03-07 14y Oxford Utd 2 at Shrewsbury Town 2
- 2011-05-07 15y Oxford Utd 0 at Shrewsbury Town 3 Mark Wright ENG-SHSB 90min 1g
- 2011-01-26 15y Shrewsbury Town 1 at Oxford Utd 3 James Constable ENG-OXFO 90min 2g
- 2006-01-07 20y Shrewsbury Town 3 at Oxford Utd 0
- 2005-04-02 21y Oxford Utd 0 at Shrewsbury Town 3
- 2004-08-28 22y Shrewsbury Town 0 at Oxford Utd 2
- 2003-03-15 23y Oxford Utd 2 at Shrewsbury Town 1
- 2002-10-26 23y Shrewsbury Town 2 at Oxford Utd 2
- 2002-01-08 24y Oxford Utd 0 at Shrewsbury Town 1
- 1996-04-23 30y Shrewsbury Town 0 at Oxford Utd 6
- 1995-10-31 30y Oxford Utd 0 at Shrewsbury Town 2
- 1995-01-28 31y Oxford Utd 1 at Shrewsbury Town 1
- 1994-10-29 31y Shrewsbury Town 0 at Oxford Utd 0