- 2026-01-24 8mo Luton Town 0 at Plymouth Argyle 1 Mathias Ross ENG-PLYM 90min yc
- 2025-09-13 1y Plymouth Argyle 3 at Luton Town 2 Bradley Ibrahim ENG-PLYM 90min 2g
- 2025-09-13 1y Luton Town 2 at Plymouth Argyle 3
- 2025-02-19 1y Plymouth Argyle 1 at Luton Town 1
- 2024-09-27 2y Luton Town 1 at Plymouth Argyle 3 Ibrahim Cissoko ENG-PLYM 32min 2g
- 2019-03-09 7y Luton Town 0 at Plymouth Argyle 0
- 2018-11-17 7y Plymouth Argyle 1 at Luton Town 5 James Steven Collins ENG-LUPE 84min 3g
- 2017-02-25 9y Plymouth Argyle 1 at Luton Town 1
- 2016-03-19 10y Luton Town 1 at Plymouth Argyle 0 Jack Marriott ENG-LUPE 90min 1g
- 2015-10-24 10y Plymouth Argyle 2 at Luton Town 1 Carl Gerard McHugh ENG-PLGG 90min 1g
- 2015-01-17 11y Luton Town 1 at Plymouth Argyle 0 Andy Drury ENG-LUPE 90min 1g
- 2008-08-13 18y Plymouth Argyle 0 at Luton Town 2 Rossi Jarvis ENG-LUPE 90min 1g
- 2007-04-14 19y Plymouth Argyle 2 at Luton Town 1
- 2006-11-29 19y Luton Town 0 at Plymouth Argyle 1
- 2006-04-17 20y Luton Town 2 at Plymouth Argyle 1
- 2004-03-20 22y Plymouth Argyle 1 at Luton Town 1
- 2003-09-13 23y Luton Town 1 at Plymouth Argyle 2
- 2003-02-25 23y Plymouth Argyle 0 at Luton Town 1
- 2002-02-02 24y Plymouth Argyle 0 at Luton Town 2
- 1998-02-28 28y Luton Town 2 at Plymouth Argyle 0
- 1997-02-08 29y Plymouth Argyle 2 at Luton Town 2
- 1996-11-02 29y Luton Town 3 at Plymouth Argyle 3