- 2026-04-11 6mo Exeter 2 at Plymouth Argyle 2
- 2025-10-23 11mo Plymouth Argyle 0 at Exeter 2 Akeel Higgins ENG-EXET 71min 1g
- 2023-04-15 3y Plymouth Argyle 1 at Exeter 0 Adam Fletcher Randell ENG-PLGG 3min
- 2022-10-31 3y Exeter 2 at Plymouth Argyle 4 Ryan Hardie ENG-PLGG 28min 1g
- 2019-10-26 6y Plymouth Argyle 0 at Exeter 4 Nicky Law ENG-EXET 86min 2g
- 2017-10-04 9y Exeter 2 at Plymouth Argyle 2 Liam James McAlinden ENG-EXET 90min 1g
- 2017-02-11 9y Exeter 0 at Plymouth Argyle 3 Ryan Paul Taylor ENG-PLGG 90min 1g
- 2016-09-17 10y Plymouth Argyle 2 at Exeter 0 Graham Carey ENG-PLGG 77min 1g
- 2016-04-02 10y Plymouth Argyle 1 at Exeter 2 Ollie Watkins ENG-EXET 90min 2g
- 2015-11-21 10y Exeter 2 at Plymouth Argyle 1 Ryan Bernard Harley ENG-EXET 90min 2g
- 2015-10-07 11y Exeter 0 at Plymouth Argyle 2 Hiram Kojo Kwarteng Boateng ENG-PLGG 90min 1g
- 2015-02-21 11y Plymouth Argyle 3 at Exeter 1 Reuben James Reid ENG-PLGG 73min 3g
- 2014-03-26 12y Exeter 2 at Plymouth Argyle 1 Liam Michael Sercombe ENG-EXET 90min 1g
- 2014-02-02 12y Plymouth Argyle 6 at Exeter 1
- 2013-10-05 13y Plymouth Argyle 1 at Exeter 3 Scot Andrew Bennett ENG-EXET 90min 1g
- 2013-03-30 13y Exeter 0 at Plymouth Argyle 1 Jake Stanley Cole ENG-PLGG 90min
- 2012-12-15 13y Plymouth Argyle 1 at Exeter 1
- 2011-08-31 15y Plymouth Argyle 1 at Exeter 1 Luke Daley ENG-PLGG 90min 1g
- 2011-04-30 15y Plymouth Argyle 0 at Exeter 1 James William Dunne ENG-EXET 90min 1g
- 2010-12-11 15y Exeter 0 at Plymouth Argyle 2 Bradley Wright-Phillips ENG-PLGG 71min 2g
- 2002-02-26 24y Exeter 0 at Plymouth Argyle 3
- 2001-04-07 25y Exeter 0 at Plymouth Argyle 1
- 2000-12-02 25y Plymouth Argyle 2 at Exeter 0
- 1999-01-30 27y Plymouth Argyle 1 at Exeter 1
- 1996-03-23 30y Plymouth Argyle 1 at Exeter 1
- 1996-01-01 30y Exeter 2 at Plymouth Argyle 2
- 1994-04-02 32y Exeter 0 at Plymouth Argyle 1
- 1994-03-02 32y Plymouth Argyle 3 at Exeter 2