- 2024-01-13 2y Stoke City FC 1 at Rotherham United 0 Lewis Baker ENG-STMU 90min 1g
- 2023-08-29 3y Rotherham United 1 at Stoke City FC 6 Josh Laurent ENG-STMU 90min 2g 1a
- 2023-08-05 3y Rotherham United 1 at Stoke City FC 4 André Filipe Cunha Vidigal ENG-STMU 90min 2g
- 2022-12-26 3y Stoke City FC 2 at Rotherham United 2
- 2022-10-18 4y Rotherham United 1 at Stoke City FC 0 Oliver Michael Rathbone ENG-RODC 82min 1g
- 2021-01-20 5y Stoke City FC 3 at Rotherham United 3
- 2020-10-31 5y Rotherham United 0 at Stoke City FC 1 James Joseph McClean ENG-STMU 90min 1g
- 2019-04-13 7y Rotherham United 2 at Stoke City FC 2
- 2018-09-29 8y Stoke City FC 2 at Rotherham United 2
- 2008-11-12 17y Rotherham United 0 at Stoke City FC 2 Danny Pugh ENG-STMU 90min 1g
- 2005-04-02 21y Rotherham United 2 at Stoke City FC 1
- 2003-04-09 23y Rotherham United 0 at Stoke City FC 2
- 2001-02-24 25y Stoke City FC 1 at Rotherham United 2
- 2000-09-23 26y Rotherham United 1 at Stoke City FC 1