- 2021-01-20 5y Barnsley 0 at Watford FC 1 Troy Deeney ENG-WAXQ 62min 1g
- 2020-10-31 5y Watford FC 0 at Barnsley 1 Alex Mowatt ENG-BAXL 90min 1g
- 2014-03-15 12y Barnsley 0 at Watford FC 3 Cristian Damián Battocchio ENG-WAXQ 90min 1g
- 2013-09-21 13y Watford FC 5 at Barnsley 1 Ikechi Anya ENG-WAXQ 90min 1g
- 2013-03-16 13y Watford FC 0 at Barnsley 1 Luke Steele ENG-BAXL 90min
- 2012-12-01 13y Barnsley 1 at Watford FC 4 Troy Deeney ENG-WAXQ 80min 2g
- 2012-02-04 14y Barnsley 1 at Watford FC 2 John Eustace ENG-WAXQ 90min 2g
- 2011-04-23 15y Barnsley 0 at Watford FC 1 John Eustace ENG-WAXQ 90min 1g yc
- 2010-11-27 15y Watford FC 0 at Barnsley 0
- 2010-02-06 16y Watford FC 0 at Barnsley 1 Emil Hallfreðsson ENG-BAXL 90min 1g
- 2009-04-11 17y Barnsley 1 at Watford FC 1
- 2008-11-15 17y Watford FC 1 at Barnsley 2 Stephen Foster ENG-BAXL 90min 1g
- 2008-04-10 18y Barnsley 3 at Watford FC 0
- 2007-11-24 18y Watford FC 2 at Barnsley 3
- 2002-03-23 24y Watford FC 0 at Barnsley 2
- 2001-11-03 24y Barnsley 0 at Watford FC 3
- 2000-12-29 25y Watford FC 1 at Barnsley 0
- 2000-08-19 26y Barnsley 0 at Watford FC 1
- 1999-05-01 27y Watford FC 2 at Barnsley 2
- 1996-02-03 30y Watford FC 1 at Barnsley 2
- 1995-08-26 31y Barnsley 3 at Watford FC 2
- 1995-03-21 31y Barnsley 2 at Watford FC 3
- 1994-09-10 32y Watford FC 0 at Barnsley 0
- 1994-04-12 32y Watford FC 1 at Barnsley 0