- 2020-11-14 5y Elgin City 0 at Arbroath 3 David Gold SCO-ARBR 90min 2g yc
- 2019-07-13 7y Elgin City 1 at Arbroath 2 Omar Kader SCO-ARBR 90min 1g
- 2018-08-16 8y Arbroath 1 at Elgin City 1 Darren Hill SCO-ARBR 90min
- 2018-07-21 8y Elgin City 0 at Arbroath 2 Colin Hamilton SCO-ARBR 90min 1g yc
- 2017-04-29 9y Elgin City 2 at Arbroath 3 Ryan McCord SCO-ARBR 83min 3g
- 2017-03-04 9y Arbroath 0 at Elgin City 0
- 2016-12-17 9y Elgin City 2 at Arbroath 3 Steven James Doris SCO-ARBR 90min 2g
- 2016-08-20 10y Arbroath 1 at Elgin City 0 Josh Skelly SCO-ARBR 90min 1g
- 2016-04-30 10y Arbroath 1 at Elgin City 4 Brian Cameron SCO-ELGI 90min 2g
- 2016-01-09 10y Elgin City 3 at Arbroath 2 Connor McLaren SCO-ELGI 76min 1g
- 2015-10-31 10y Arbroath 0 at Elgin City 2 Brian Cameron SCO-ELGI 90min 1g
- 2015-08-08 11y Elgin City 3 at Arbroath 0 Craig Gunn SCO-ELGI 84min 2g
- 2015-04-11 11y Arbroath 1 at Elgin City 2 Shane Sutherland SCO-ELGI 90min 1g
- 2015-02-28 11y Elgin City 3 at Arbroath 3
- 2014-12-03 11y Arbroath 1 at Elgin City 1
- 2014-09-27 12y Elgin City 0 at Arbroath 1 Simon Murray SCO-ARBR 85min 1g yc
- 2012-07-28 14y Arbroath 7 at Elgin City 5 Darren Gribben SCO-ARBR 90min 3g
- 2011-05-07 15y Elgin City 5 at Arbroath 3 David Gormley SCO-ELGI 90min 3g
- 2011-02-26 15y Arbroath 2 at Elgin City 3 Mark Ross Nicolson SCO-ELGI 90min 1g
- 2011-02-24 15y Elgin City 0 at Arbroath 2 Gavin Swankie SCO-ARBR 90min 1g
- 2010-08-07 16y Arbroath 5 at Elgin City 3 Keith Gibson SCO-ARBR 84min 2g
- 2007-10-27 18y Elgin City 0 at Arbroath 5
- 2007-03-24 19y Arbroath 1 at Elgin City 0
- 2007-03-07 19y Elgin City 1 at Arbroath 2
- 2006-12-16 19y Arbroath 4 at Elgin City 0
- 2006-09-30 20y Elgin City 1 at Arbroath 2
- 2006-08-09 20y Elgin City 1 at Arbroath 0