- 2026-09-26 1mo Elgin City 1 at Peterhead 0
- 2025-04-19 1y Peterhead 0 at Elgin City 4 Russell Dingwall SCO-ELGC 90min 1g 1a
- 2025-03-01 1y Elgin City 0 at Peterhead 2 Kieran Shanks SCO-PETE 80min 1g
- 2024-12-28 1y Peterhead 0 at Elgin City 2 Lewis Hyde SCO-ELGC 90min 1g yc
- 2024-10-05 2y Elgin City 1 at Peterhead 0
- 2024-07-20 2y Elgin City 2 at Peterhead 4 Jason Brown SCO-PETE 90min 2g
- 2024-04-20 2y Peterhead 1 at Elgin City 1
- 2024-02-24 2y Elgin City 1 at Peterhead 1
- 2023-12-30 2y Peterhead 1 at Elgin City 2 Ryan MacLeman SCO-ELGC 90min 1g
- 2023-09-30 3y Elgin City 0 at Peterhead 6 Kieran Shanks SCO-PETE 90min 2g 1a
- 2022-09-24 4y Elgin City 4 at Peterhead 0 Kane Jay Hester SCO-ELGI 83min 1g
- 2019-04-20 7y Peterhead 2 at Elgin City 1 Jack Leitch SCO-PETE 90min 1g
- 2019-03-02 7y Elgin City 0 at Peterhead 1 Patrick Joseph Gerard Boyle SCO-PETE 90min 1g
- 2018-12-29 7y Peterhead 3 at Elgin City 0 Jack Leitch SCO-PETE 90min 2g
- 2018-10-06 8y Elgin City 0 at Peterhead 3 Ryan Dow SCO-PETE 74min 1g
- 2018-04-21 8y Peterhead 1 at Elgin City 0 Jason Brown SCO-PETE 90min 1g yc
- 2018-01-02 8y Elgin City 0 at Peterhead 7 James Stevenson SCO-PETE 90min 2g
- 2017-11-04 9y Peterhead 2 at Elgin City 0 Rory McAllister SCO-PETE 87min 2g
- 2017-07-29 9y Peterhead 3 at Elgin City 0 David McCracken SCO-PETE 90min 1g
- 2014-03-08 12y Peterhead 3 at Elgin City 2 Rory McAllister SCO-PETE 90min 2g
- 2014-01-02 12y Elgin City 1 at Peterhead 2 Graeme Sharp SCO-PETE 90min 1g
- 2013-11-09 13y Peterhead 4 at Elgin City 2 Rory McAllister SCO-PETE 90min 2g
- 2013-08-24 13y Elgin City 2 at Peterhead 2
- 2012-03-10 14y Peterhead 2 at Elgin City 1 Martin Bavidge SCO-PETE 86min 1g
- 2012-02-15 14y Peterhead 1 at Elgin City 6 Brian Cameron SCO-ELGI 90min 1g
- 2012-01-02 14y Elgin City 0 at Peterhead 3 Graeme Sharp SCO-PETE 90min 1g
- 2011-09-10 15y Elgin City 3 at Peterhead 1 Jamie Duff SCO-ELGI 90min 1g
- 2001-05-01 25y Elgin City 1 at Peterhead 1