- 2024-08-03 2y Everton 3 at Preston North End FC 0
- 2004-10-27 22y Preston North End FC 0 at Everton 2
- 1961-02-25 65y Everton 0 at Preston North End FC 1
- 1960-10-08 66y Preston North End FC 0 at Everton 0
- 1960-02-27 66y Preston North End FC 0 at Everton 4
- 1959-12-05 66y Everton 0 at Preston North End FC 0
- 1958-09-01 68y Everton 1 at Preston North End FC 3
- 1958-08-27 68y Preston North End FC 4 at Everton 1
- 1958-03-08 68y Preston North End FC 2 at Everton 4
- 1957-10-26 69y Everton 1 at Preston North End FC 3
- 1957-02-27 69y Preston North End FC 4 at Everton 1
- 1955-12-17 70y Everton 1 at Preston North End FC 0
- 1955-08-20 71y Preston North End FC 4 at Everton 0
- 1955-01-01 71y Everton 0 at Preston North End FC 0
- 1949-02-19 77y Everton 1 at Preston North End FC 3
- 1948-09-25 78y Preston North End FC 1 at Everton 4
- 1948-04-17 78y Everton 0 at Preston North End FC 3
- 1947-11-29 78y Preston North End FC 1 at Everton 2
- 1947-04-26 79y Preston North End FC 0 at Everton 2
- 1946-12-21 79y Everton 1 at Preston North End FC 2
- 1939-04-15 87y Preston North End FC 0 at Everton 0
- 1938-12-10 87y Everton 1 at Preston North End FC 0
- 1938-03-12 88y Everton 1 at Preston North End FC 2
- 1937-10-30 89y Preston North End FC 5 at Everton 3
- 1937-04-14 89y Everton 0 at Preston North End FC 1
- 1937-01-01 89y Preston North End FC 2 at Everton 2
- 1936-05-02 90y Preston North End FC 0 at Everton 5
- 1935-09-18 91y Everton 2 at Preston North End FC 2
- 1935-01-05 91y Everton 2 at Preston North End FC 2
- 1934-09-01 92y Preston North End FC 1 at Everton 4
- 1925-04-13 101y Preston North End FC 0 at Everton 0
- 1925-04-10 101y Everton 1 at Preston North End FC 1
- 1924-02-09 102y Everton 1 at Preston North End FC 0
- 1924-02-06 102y Preston North End FC 1 at Everton 1
- 1923-05-05 103y Everton 2 at Preston North End FC 2
- 1923-04-28 103y Preston North End FC 0 at Everton 1
- 1922-04-10 104y Preston North End FC 0 at Everton 0
- 1922-03-18 104y Everton 0 at Preston North End FC 1
- 1921-04-16 105y Everton 0 at Preston North End FC 1
- 1921-04-09 105y Preston North End FC 1 at Everton 0
- 1920-05-01 106y Preston North End FC 1 at Everton 0
- 1920-04-26 106y Everton 1 at Preston North End FC 1
- 1913-12-27 112y Everton 0 at Preston North End FC 1
- 1913-09-06 113y Preston North End FC 0 at Everton 2
- 1912-03-23 114y Preston North End FC 0 at Everton 1
- 1911-11-18 114y Everton 1 at Preston North End FC 2
- 1911-01-07 115y Everton 2 at Preston North End FC 0
- 1910-09-10 116y Preston North End FC 0 at Everton 2
- 1909-01-09 117y Everton 3 at Preston North End FC 3
- 1908-09-12 118y Preston North End FC 1 at Everton 0