- 2015-10-07 11y Notts County 1 at Sheffield Utd 5 Jose Baxter WOR-SHEF 71min 2g
- 2015-02-18 11y Sheffield Utd 2 at Notts County 1 James Murphy WOR-SHEF 90min 1g
- 2014-11-29 11y Notts County 1 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 2014-01-11 12y Sheffield Utd 1 at Notts County 2 Enoch Olusesan Showunmi ENG-NOGE 90min 1g
- 2013-01-19 13y Sheffield Utd 1 at Notts County 1
- 2012-10-18 14y Sheffield Utd 4 at Notts County 1 Harry Maguire WOR-SHEF 90min 2g
- 2012-09-29 14y Notts County 1 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 2012-03-21 14y Sheffield Utd 5 at Notts County 2 Neill Collins WOR-SHEF 90min 1g
- 2011-12-27 14y Notts County 1 at Sheffield Utd 2 Ryan Flynn WOR-SHEF 90min 1g
- 1995-03-11 31y Sheffield Utd 1 at Notts County 2
- 1994-08-27 32y Notts County 3 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1992-04-19 34y Sheffield Utd 3 at Notts County 1
- 1991-09-16 35y Notts County 3 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1926-03-13 100y Notts County 0 at Sheffield Utd 3
- 1925-10-31 101y Sheffield Utd 0 at Notts County 2
- 1925-04-18 101y Notts County 0 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 1924-12-13 101y Sheffield Utd 0 at Notts County 2
- 1924-04-07 102y Notts County 1 at Sheffield Utd 3
- 1924-04-05 102y Sheffield Utd 2 at Notts County 0
- 1919-10-02 107y Sheffield Utd 2 at Notts County 2
- 1919-09-01 107y Notts County 0 at Sheffield Utd 3
- 1915-04-02 111y Sheffield Utd 1 at Notts County 3
- 1913-04-05 113y Sheffield Utd 1 at Notts County 0
- 1912-11-30 113y Notts County 0 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 1912-03-30 114y Notts County 3 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1911-11-25 114y Sheffield Utd 0 at Notts County 2
- 1911-04-08 115y Notts County 2 at Sheffield Utd 0
- 1910-12-03 115y Sheffield Utd 3 at Notts County 0
- 1909-03-13 117y Notts County 2 at Sheffield Utd 3
- 1908-11-07 117y Sheffield Utd 1 at Notts County 3
- 1908-03-21 118y Sheffield Utd 3 at Notts County 0
- 1907-11-23 118y Notts County 1 at Sheffield Utd 0
- 1907-04-01 119y Sheffield Utd 0 at Notts County 4
- 1906-12-26 119y Notts County 1 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 1906-01-01 120y Notts County 0 at Sheffield Utd 1
- 1905-12-26 120y Sheffield Utd 3 at Notts County 2
- 1905-01-28 121y Sheffield Utd 5 at Notts County 1
- 1904-10-01 122y Notts County 1 at Sheffield Utd 2
- 1904-04-04 122y Sheffield Utd 1 at Notts County 2
- 1903-10-10 123y Notts County 1 at Sheffield Utd 3
- 1903-04-10 123y Notts County 0 at Sheffield Utd 3
- 1902-10-25 124y Sheffield Utd 1 at Notts County 1
- 1902-03-08 124y Sheffield Utd 0 at Notts County 4
- 1901-11-09 124y Notts County 0 at Sheffield Utd 3