- 2024-10-05 2y Carlisle United FC 0 at Colchester United 0
- 2023-02-18 3y Colchester United 0 at Carlisle United FC 1 Alfie John McCalmont ENG-CAQF 84min 1g
- 2022-08-06 4y Carlisle United FC 1 at Colchester United 1
- 2022-02-12 4y Carlisle United FC 2 at Colchester United 2
- 2021-08-07 5y Colchester United 0 at Carlisle United FC 0
- 2021-03-02 5y Carlisle United FC 1 at Colchester United 2 Callum Kyle Harriott ENG-COLWM 90min 2g
- 2020-03-07 6y Colchester United 3 at Carlisle United FC 0 Kwame Afriyie Adubofour Poku ENG-COLWM 88min 2g
- 2019-12-21 6y Carlisle United FC 0 at Colchester United 3 Cohen Conrad Bramall ENG-COLWM 90min 1g
- 2019-02-23 7y Carlisle United FC 1 at Colchester United 1
- 2018-12-15 7y Colchester United 0 at Carlisle United FC 4 Daniel Grainger ENG-CAQF 90min 1g
- 2018-02-10 8y Colchester United 1 at Carlisle United FC 1
- 2017-10-14 9y Carlisle United FC 1 at Colchester United 0 Jamie Martin Devitt ENG-CAQF 44min 1g
- 2017-01-07 9y Carlisle United FC 1 at Colchester United 4 Kurtis Guthrie ENG-COLWM 90min 3g
- 2016-10-01 10y Colchester United 0 at Carlisle United FC 2 Jason Brian Kennedy ENG-CAQF 90min 1g
- 2014-01-18 12y Colchester United 4 at Carlisle United FC 2 Sanchez Watt ENG-COLWM 82min 2g
- 2013-04-27 13y Colchester United 2 at Carlisle United FC 0 Thomas Michael Eastman ENG-COLWM 90min 1g
- 2012-10-20 14y Carlisle United FC 0 at Colchester United 2 Jabo Ibehre ENG-COLWM 85min 1g
- 2012-03-24 14y Carlisle United FC 1 at Colchester United 1
- 2011-11-26 14y Colchester United 0 at Carlisle United FC 1 Paul Thirlwell ENG-CAQF 90min 1g
- 2011-04-16 15y Colchester United 1 at Carlisle United FC 4 Craig Carl Curran ENG-CAQF 90min 2g
- 2010-03-13 16y Colchester United 1 at Carlisle United FC 2 Jason Jeffrey Price ENG-CAQF 90min 1g yc
- 2010-02-03 16y Carlisle United FC 1 at Colchester United 2 Clive Platt ENG-COLWM 90min 1g
- 2009-01-31 17y Colchester United 2 at Carlisle United FC 0 David Philip Perkins ENG-COLWM 90min 1g
- 2008-10-25 18y Carlisle United FC 0 at Colchester United 5 Mark Yeates ENG-COLWM 83min 2g
- 1997-01-18 29y Carlisle United FC 1 at Colchester United 1
- 1996-10-01 30y Colchester United 0 at Carlisle United FC 3
- 1995-04-29 31y Carlisle United FC 1 at Colchester United 0
- 1994-10-15 32y Colchester United 0 at Carlisle United FC 0
- 1994-05-07 32y Colchester United 0 at Carlisle United FC 2